Marnette Haynes asked Monica Walters:

Hi Monica. I love to read, but is it rude to give a not so great review on a book you have read (especially if the story line was really good), because of missing words, spelling errors, repeat words or sentences. Also, should you let the author know. And is there someone they actual pay to proof read?

Monica Walters Hello!

I'm sorry this response is soooo late! I'd forgotten all about this feature on Goodreads and never noticed any notifications of questions being asked.

It's not rude to give a constructive review. It's only rude when the review comes off as bashing instead of offering constructive criticism. I would absolutely try to reach out to the author and let them know. If its only in a couple of instances, I would overlook it. However, if it was to the point where it interrupted the flow of the book, I would definitely reach out.
Some people edit their own books, but it's always helpful to hire another pair of eyes. In this day and age of the independent author, it can be quite costly to get a professional editor though.

flag