
A Goodreads user
asked
Stuart Aken:
Hello Stuart, When do you know that a chapter/story is really finished being written?
Stuart Aken
It's a movable feast, Emeline. You self-edit before sending work off to the publisher, reaching a stage where continuing to tweak no longer seems to enhance the story. The editor at the publisher's makes some other adjustments, almost always improving the piece. The book's published and you write something else, something different. But, later you revisit the original piece, the published work, and you see places where it could be improved.
This happens with all created work because the creator, the artist if you like, learns the trade, the craft over a lifetime. Most writers are their own most severe critics (beware any artist who claims to have produced something perfect!) so we will always find ways to improve our work as we mature and gain in experience.
There is, as you will now realise, no particular time when a piece of writing has reached the 'finished' stage. All we can do is recognise that, for the time being, the story is as good as we can make it, in the full knowledge that we will look back in a few years and identify faults and inadequacies. Such, I'm afraid, is the lot of the creative artist.
I hope that helps, though I suspect not. For your own work, the best I can advise is that you read it aloud as a final exercise, preferably from a printer script, not on screen. This 'final' check will reveal things you missed on screen and when reading silently. After these mistakes or failures of expression have been dealt with, send it off. As Wellington said, of a somewhat different issue, 'Publish and be damned!'
Good luck with your writing.
This happens with all created work because the creator, the artist if you like, learns the trade, the craft over a lifetime. Most writers are their own most severe critics (beware any artist who claims to have produced something perfect!) so we will always find ways to improve our work as we mature and gain in experience.
There is, as you will now realise, no particular time when a piece of writing has reached the 'finished' stage. All we can do is recognise that, for the time being, the story is as good as we can make it, in the full knowledge that we will look back in a few years and identify faults and inadequacies. Such, I'm afraid, is the lot of the creative artist.
I hope that helps, though I suspect not. For your own work, the best I can advise is that you read it aloud as a final exercise, preferably from a printer script, not on screen. This 'final' check will reveal things you missed on screen and when reading silently. After these mistakes or failures of expression have been dealt with, send it off. As Wellington said, of a somewhat different issue, 'Publish and be damned!'
Good luck with your writing.
More Answered Questions
D. Powell
asked
Stuart Aken:
Hi, Stuart. I merely shared an observation that I have come to believe. All writers, IMO, have introduced or will share a memory of their life somewhere, in the expansion of time, now. Perhaps your POV is different than mine? That's great. Thanks for your special abilities to process a good story.
Scott Evans
asked
Stuart Aken:
Hi, I noticed you marked my book to read, and thought you'd might enjoy a free advanced release e-copy of the brand new comedy, family saga, fantasy, sci-fi "11,984" ? This is not a conventional novel. It contains a lot of creative innovations, including punctuation from the future. scotttalbotevans@gmail.com
About Goodreads Q&A
Ask and answer questions about books!
You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.
See Featured Authors Answering Questions
Learn more