Thoughtless (Thoughtless, #1) Thoughtless discussion


1604 views
Kellen Kyle or Christian Grey?

Comments Showing 1-50 of 380 (380 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8

message 1: by Lyndsay (last edited Oct 28, 2012 04:23PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Lyndsay Matteo If these characters existed which man would you want more?

I loved both of these characters so this is a tough one but I think I'm leaning more towards Kellen because his character seems so much more realistic to me. Don't get me wrong I love the idea of Christian Grey in all his darkness and kinky fuckery but I love all of the dimensions to Kellen more.


Emma Matthews Kellen Kyle without a doubt.


Kolleen Serrano Kellan kyle definitely!:)


Deon Kellan Kyle hands down. Just to wake up to his face and Mornin' would make my day;)


Jdursi that's a tough one but over all i'd want to wake up every mornin' with KELLAN!


Gwen ~the Book Diva They are both yummy but Christian Grey has my heart!


Slipperyvowels honestly i want both ....greedy right lol...but im also gonna be very bad and add 2 others: Gideon Cross (Bared to u/Reflected in u) and Professor Gabriel Emerson (Gabriel's Inferno and Rapture).....now who is brave enough to choose from the four.....


Lyndsay Matteo Well now that just isn't fair! Now you have me questioning who else to add to that list...Travis Maddox for example? lol.


Slipperyvowels Lyndsay wrote: "Well now that just isn't fair! Now you have me questioning who else to add to that list...Travis Maddox for example? lol."

lol......good one :)


Sonia Oooh, this one is a tough one. Between Kellan and Christian, I'm going to have to go with Kellan though. I think in the books, he's more, developed as a character? More, realistic?


Clary A Kellan Kyle!!! <3 among all the sensual characters I've encountered in my previous reading Kyle is the best and the sweetest :)) I feel the connection with him (weird?)


message 12: by Jax (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jax Team Kellan!! <3


Georgia Cruz Do ya have to think? Of course Kellan Kyle! Gaaaah! :)


message 14: by Prim (new) - rated it 5 stars

Prim I love both of them but I can't choose one because they have their differences, mainly.. Kellan is a rockstar while Christian is a CEO.


message 15: by D (new) - rated it 3 stars

D Kellan! Why would you even compare them!


♬♪ ♪♬Stephanie♬♪ ♪♬   I'd be greedy and have them both, depends on what mood I'm in and how dangerous I feel :-)


Lorna Ahhh Thats SO hard! but i think i would have to go with Christian! i still love Kellan though!


Betina Patricia KELLAN KYLE FOR SURE!


Sonia Clary wrote: "Kellan Kyle!!! <3 among all the sensual characters I've encountered in my previous reading Kyle is the best and the sweetest :)) I feel the connection with him (weird?)"

Not at all. :) I think the majority of females that read the book did too.


message 20: by Deon (new) - rated it 5 stars

Deon My question would be
1.Christian or Gideon
2. Kellan/Jake or Cash
and for the funny and erotic Hamilton (the redhead series or Nev (about last night)....hmmmm


Tammy Kellan Kyle hands down! So over Christian Gray, lol. Don't forget the Hot Bunch Boys from KA's Rock Chicks. Luke Stark is second only to Kellan Kyle. Kellan is my favorite book boyfriend of all times!

In response to Deon....
1. Christian (Gideon scares me - he's psycho)
2. Kellan (yumalicious)


message 22: by Hail (new) - rated it 5 stars

Hail This is tough, but I'd have to say Kellan. There was something so much more meaningful about his love for Kiera and the way he expressed it. Something simple and organic about their love for each other. As much as I loved Christian, his control freakery is probably more than I can handle!!

And I have to agree with Tam to Deon:
1. Christian (Gideon scares me - he's psycho - NO THANKS!)
2. Kellan - no other rocker compares


message 23: by Jessica (new) - added it

Jessica Kellan Kyle hands down there is no question!!


Literati Literature Lovers Today we are celebrating S.C. StephensDay Literati Literature Lovers. Be sure to check out the fun links celebrating her day! http://literatiliteraturelovers.com/t...


Mitzi No contest - Kellan!


Sabrina Muhlmeyer Christian Grey!!!! XOXOXOX


Gwen ~the Book Diva Sabrina wrote: "Christian Grey!!!! XOXOXOX"

Yay! Finally someone else on my side. I was starting to feel lonely! LOL


message 28: by Jen (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jen Mekay wrote: "honestly i want both ....greedy right lol...but im also gonna be very bad and add 2 others: Gideon Cross (Bared to u/Reflected in u) and Professor Gabriel Emerson (Gabriel's Inferno and Rapture)......"
I like your thinking!!! And yes add Travis!!!


message 29: by Jen (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jen Kallen for sure!!! I'm a sucker for rocker boys with tattoos! Don't get me wrong, loved Christian but for me it's Kallen all the way!!!


Sweetestsummer KELLAN KYLE!!! swoooooon


Meghna Sweetestsummer wrote: "KELLAN KYLE!!! swoooooon"
ditto :)


Beatriz KELLAN KYLE HANDS DOWN!!!


Sleepy Oooh so hard to choosei love me some Christian gray my first book love!! But o how kellan is a rock God!! But since u did add Travis in there!!!;) I think my guess from those three would HAVE to be Travis Maddox I'm a sucker for tattooed bad boys!!!!! But since Travis wasn't part of the original question I think I may need to go with Mr. Christian gray!!! I love my sweet rock kellan but Christian is this man who knows what he wants and goes after it!!! And if he were real and wanted me ooh he probably would not have to work too hard!!! Lmao!!!;)


Sleepy And Christian would never cheat and made sure she was single sorry kellan, u still stole ur best friends girl!!! Lol!


Jennifer Wow with the three of them I don't know who I would pick. I love a hot guy with Tattoo's and that can express his feelings. Christian plays things to close to the vest and does not open up. Travis is sweet but not really my type and Kellan yes he did take his friends girl but he has not cheated on her and is a rock god. So I guess I would have to pick Kellan.


Moonriver77 Easy peasy ... Kellen Mon-Wed, Travis Thurs-Sat and fifty on Sundays and bank holidays. Gabriel didn't appeal to me at all.


Lyndsay Matteo Moonriver77 wrote: "Easy peasy ... Kellen Mon-Wed, Travis Thurs-Sat and fifty on Sundays and bank holidays. Gabriel didn't appeal to me at all."

I like your way of thinking! ;)


Krystal Kellan for sure!


message 39: by Mia (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mia Kellan Kyle for suuure,no doubt !!


Sleepy Moonriver77 finally someone agrees with me Gabriel didn't really appeal to me either! I thought I was the only one not thinking he was this sexy alpha male!!! Lol


Carrie Kellan Kyle !


message 42: by V (new) - rated it 5 stars

V Mekay wrote: "honestly i want both ....greedy right lol...but im also gonna be very bad and add 2 others: Gideon Cross (Bared to u/Reflected in u) and Professor Gabriel Emerson (Gabriel's Inferno and Rapture)......"

I would have to agree with you Mekay, but we are forgetting William Honor.... I don't think I can choose!


message 43: by Ann (new) - rated it 3 stars

Ann Landiza KELLAN KYLE has my heart!!

At least he's not abusive. Well, I love Christian too, but I'm a big sucker for rockstars. xD


Chrissy As much as I loved Christian, I have to pick Kellen. They are both messed up but Kellen's issues are a lot easier to fix then Christians. Although I think Christian could be a helluva lota fun. LOL Although Kellen seems to be fun too, just in a more sedate way. Ohhh so okay obviously I can not choose so can I just have them both??????????????


Kimberly Christian Grey.... :))


Amanda Kellan Kyle!!!


Kendra Christen has the money, but Kellen has everything else, that bad boy rocker, so it has to be Kellen for me.


Electa Christian Grey all day but ill cheat with kellan


Gwen ~the Book Diva Electa wrote: "Christian Grey all day but ill cheat with kellan"

Love it! Hahahaha!


message 50: by [deleted user] (new)

Both please! :D But if i HAD to choose, it would have to be Christian. I just wanted Kellen to man up and make Kiera choose or better yet, forget her and convince Denny to too.


« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8
back to top

all discussions on this book | post a new topic


Books mentioned in this topic

Thoughtless (other topics)

Authors mentioned in this topic

S.C. Stephens (other topics)