Review Group discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Finished rounds
>
Round 4 - Group 3
date
newest »
newest »
Steve, you're quite right. Jay is on vacation, and I'm doing the mod work this week (yi yi yi) with help from other mods. Your solution won't work, however. I'm set up to review you in Round 3, right? I've just written to you asking for your book. So you can't review me in Round 4.
We can take you off your review in Round 4 and find someone else to review Marie-Anne. Anyone else see a different solution?
Mods, I'm taking this offline to email to get your thoughts on related matters of replacement.
I've downloaded Neel Kay's book, and will begin reading it tonight.
Hi. I see I'm scheduled to review Anne's book. Anne looks like a lovely person, and her book is getting great reviews. I am not a fan of fantasy of any kind, nor of paranormal anything, so I think I'm a bad match for this review. May I switch or beg off? No one should get a bad match, IMHO. I wouldn't want someone who doesn't like mysteries to review my book, e.g.
Sandra, I happen to be the moderator this week, pinch-hitting for Jay, so I need to be the one to answer your request, even though it's my book lol. Actually, the book is very lightly paranormal; it's mostly a women's issues book. Rabid paranormal/fantasy readers in general don't like it. I can tell you that making switches is VERY difficult, and we have agreed we will only allow it if the objection is extreme--like it's against someone's religion. As an example, Mike just reviewed a Christian book, and he's a-religious. So, the bottom line is, I have to say no. Your reactions, even though you're not a paranormal reader (I'm not either, by the way)will be just as valuable to me. Okay? If you would please PM me your email address, I'll send you my PDF. Thanks for understanding!
Steve wrote: "Would it be all right if I read one of the books from Mike's Nominate for Review thread instead? And bring in someone else who has not reviewed/been reviewed by Marie Anne to review her book?Anoth..."
Steve, those are good ideas. I'm about to try to get us a replacement for Elizabeth and also a pinch-hitter for you. So let's reconnect later on, after I make that try. Whom did you have in mind to review Marie-Anne? That would be a big help...we could use more pinch-hitters.
Jay wrote: "When you receive the book you are reviewing please post a link to the book here on the round thread. That way the author can check you have the correct file, and the mods can check you are all on t..."SYLVIE HAS REPLACED ELIZABETH. WHERE YOU SEE AN XXXX, PUT SYLVIE'S NAME IN. HERE IS HER LINK.
http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/...
ADDED ON NOVEMBER 3
I'll definitely try that next, if need be. In the meantime I've asked someone who's a read-only member. Have to wait until I hear back. Appreciate your helping me out, Steve!
Anne wrote: "Sandra, I happen to be the moderator this week, pinch-hitting for Jay, so I need to be the one to answer your request, even though it's my book lol. Actually, the book is very lightly paranormal; ..."Thank you for being so gracious, Anne! I've received the book, and read the first 3 chapters, and am happy to review it. Maybe it's because the protagonist shares my hair color. ;-)
Alrighty now! I'm going to have to start calling you Marlena!
Steve wrote: "Anne wrote: "I'll definitely try that next, if need be. In the meantime I've asked someone who's a read-only member. Have to wait until I hear back. Appreciate your helping me out, Steve!"Well, sure...nice offer. I'm sure she won't mind! Steve, if you wouldn't mind contacting Sylvie and explaining why you're asking for her book, that would be great.
Sandra wrote: "I've downloaded Neel Kay's book, and will begin reading it tonight."Thanks, Sandra. Confirming for Round 3 you'll be reviewing
http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/15...
Right?
Steve wrote: "currently reading Sylvie's bookhttp://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13..."
Thanks, Steve!
Steve, no grass grows under your feet. What a guy.
Folks, Lauren (a reviewer-only member) has enthusiastically agreed to review Marie-Anne's Whorticulture for Round 4, since Steve has a reciprocal problem.Steve could be restng on his laurels, but instead he'll be reviewing Sylvie's book(she'll get a double shot this time), just to be a nice guy.
Hurrahs all around!
Is that for this round Steve? I thought I was reviewing Sylvie's book.
Oh -it's OK - just read Anne's comment. Sorry I am not with it. In the middle of a book blog tour and it's exhausting - fun though.
It is a bit like swimming in soup yes. I am at a loss to find the nearest purveyor of bitter. I fear it will involve swimming 'the sleeve' which must be a little like swimming in soup anyway.
Anne wrote: "Sandra wrote: "I've downloaded Neel Kay's book, and will begin reading it tonight."Thanks, Sandra. Confirming for Round 3 you'll be reviewing
http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/15......"
Yes, that's right, I'm more than halfway through now.
I have Sandra's book and am reading it.
I've received Kerry Dwyer's book to review for Round 4 (starting Dec. 8). Here's the link on Goodreads.http://www.goodreads.com/search?utf8=...
I have received Kathryn's book and will be reviewing it after I've had my share of turkey.http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/16...
Happy holidays/shopping...
I have posted my review of Kathy's Desire at http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/.... I will wait to see if Kathryn wants me to post it anywhere else as she has, I believe, the right to ask that I remove this review.
Hock wrote: "I have posted my review of Kathy's Desire at http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/.... I will wait to see if Kathryn wants me to post it anywhere else as she has, I believe, the right to ask..."Hi Hock, no, authors do not have the right to ask reviewers to remove reviews on goodreads because that is not fair to the reviewer.
Marie-Anne wrote: "Hock wrote: "I have posted my review of Kathy's Desire at http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/.... I will wait to see if Kathryn wants me to post it anywhere else as she has, I believe, the..."O.K. Thanks for the clarification. I'll still wait for indication from Kathryn if she wants me to post elsewhere.
Did I read somewhere that Steve had dropped out of the group? Then who am I reviewing in round 4?
Would you like a real treat? Without Steve you have no-one to review, and Marie-Anne has no-one to give her a review. How about reviewing her book instead? It's been very highly rated by the members who have read it so far. Your alternative is to accept the free ride for this round.
I'll read Marie-Anne's. Have noticed its great reviews, so obviously I'm curious.. :)
Just PM her, Neel. I'm sure she'll be up for it :)
Hock wrote: "Marie-Anne wrote: "Hock wrote: "I have posted my review of Kathy's Desire at http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/.... I will wait to see if Kathryn wants me to post it anywhere else as she ..."Sorry Hock, I didn't see your message until just now. It's fine on here only. Of course I wouldn't ask for it to be removed from Goodreads. That would be bad form especially since the point of this group is to give honest reviews.
Jay wrote: "Would you like a real treat? Without Steve you have no-one to review, and Marie-Anne has no-one to give her a review. How about reviewing her book instead? It's been very highly rated by the member..."I don't know if Marie-Anne told you, but if not, I am excited to do so. I joined LinkedIn, and one of my contacts there wrote on my blog that she was going on my recommendation of Marie-Anne's book and she purchased it due to the review on my blog! :) That is the reason I started this blog to give all of us indies the exposure. I am so happy to have been part of that! :)
Kathryn wrote: "Hock wrote: "Marie-Anne wrote: "Hock wrote: "I have posted my review of Kathy's Desire at http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/.... I will wait to see if Kathryn wants me to post it anywhere..."O.K. thanks.
Rebecca wrote: "Jay wrote: "Would you like a real treat? Without Steve you have no-one to review, and Marie-Anne has no-one to give her a review. How about reviewing her book instead? It's been very highly rated b..."Great news, Rebecca :) Keep up the good work. Marie-Anne's book is worthy of all the exposure we can give it, as are several more that I've come across from the RG members.
Hey, I've only just noticed that: RG on GR!
I've posted my review for Kerry's "Ramblings in Ireland" just now, which I enjoyed. This concludes my Group 3 reviews. Here's the link:http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...
Thank you Anne. That is lovely :)
Here is my review of Hock's The Battle of Chibi:http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...
And merry Xmas folks!
I've lost track, Marie-Anne - did you want me to ask one of our readers to review your book as you're missing out in this round?
I lost track too! Don't worry, the deadline is tight.
My review of Sandra's The Hounding is up on Goodreadshttp://www.goodreads.com/review/show/... and on Amazon.
My review of Anne's Homeschooling: The Fire Night Ball is up at http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/... and on Amazon
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
When you post you review on GR post a link to the review here on the round thread so that we can all get to it easily, and again it will make the mods lives easier.
Thank you :)
Round 4 Start date: 08 December 2012
End date: 29 December 2012
Sylvie reviews Alexes
Neel reviews xxxx
Anne reviews Kerry
Hock reviews Kathryn
Alexes reviews Sandra
xxxxx reviews Marie-Anne
Kerry reviews Sylvie
Kathryn reviews Neel
Sandra reviews Anne
Marie-Anne reviews Hock
Neel http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/...
Anne http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/...
Hock http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/...
Alexes http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/...
Steve has withdrawn
Kerry http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/...
Kathryn http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/...
Sandra http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/...
Marie-Anne http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/...
Sylvie http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/...
(Sylvie replaces Elizabeth)