Shadow Falls Series discussion

Who do you want Kylie to end up with? Why?
who do you like better?
Do you like werewolfs or faes?

Derek all the way because he truly loves Kylie for who she is. :)

Derek!!! He can read her emothions better literally and was always there for her. Yet I do have to say I loke werewolves better but just by a hair.

Personally, I'd be fine with either of them, I think they both have done certain things that show they care about her, and at the same time have kind of made mistakes along the same lines.

Derek. So far, he hasn't done much to break Kylie's heart. Lucas, on the other hand, has. He makes her wait, and doesn't tell her what's going on. He leaves her in the dark. What he is basically stops them from being together. It also seems like he doesn't fully appreciate that Kylie isn't a werewolf. Derek is the one for Kylie. He can give her so much more. But, Derek also has his faults. I don't really want to choose either one of them, but if I have to choose then it would be Derek.

I've decided that since everyone else is going Derek, I'm gonna be the one to show Lucas some love.Everyone thinks Lucas is the bad guy because of what he did in Whispers at Moonrise, however don't forget what Derek did with Ellie when he supposedly was crushing on Kylie. Also, a lot of Lucas's insecurities about Kylie's ghosts and Derek being around her can be summed up to him being a werewolf, and his rotten life before camp.

EMILY!!! Derek is the best (sorry). I have been going for him since the first book and whispers at moonrise just added to Derek.

It feels wrong to me to let Lucas get completely pounded.

Well, I kinda like them both, too. I like how Kylie kind of grew up with Lucas and how he protects her (not that derek does'nt.) He is a good guy, just I think derek is better.

I like them both but I think Kylie is always going to have an issue with Derek because he can sense and control her emotions. Also, Lucas and Kylie have history and that is so hard to let go. Neither are very trustworthy if you ask me. I would like her to find someone else entirely. I know a lot of people wont agree with that but I think it would be best

Kimber wrote: "I like them both but I think Kylie is always going to have an issue with Derek because he can sense and control her emotions. Also, Lucas and Kylie have history and that is so hard to let go. Neith..."

I completely agree with you!

Team Derek!! I am team Derek all the way because he never really hurt Kylie, he just pushed her away to settle on his own feelings. He understands her like none other. He says he loves here and really doesn't expect anything back from her. He understood why she couldn't say I love you back to him, and was okay with it.

Lucus= WOW is all i have to say! How could he marry someone else and have her find out by him not telling her!! That was just sad. Kylie was so heart broken by him it was just sad. That shows that he really didn't even care for him to do something like that.

I am team Derek!!! But i have a feeling against all logic C.C. Hunter will put Kylie and Lucus together to give the book a twist, but i sure hope that Kylie and Derek end up together.

I can't decided either! Derek has been their for her, told her he loves her( when he figures it out)he sounds, hot And sweet And Sexy. Lucas has only told her half truth and tells kylie that he loves her AFTER he breaks her heart. lucas is Sexy and dangerous. both guys are TALL,DARK AND HANDSOME. i would be confused about who i love more too!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I don't hate either of the guys but I myself am a bit of a control freak. I know it would REALLY bother me if someone had access to controlling how I feel. And to top that off, when Derek felt like he and Kylie were getting too close, he ran away. Yes it was because he was asked to go on a mission but what happened on this mission? Don't yall remember that when it came down to it, he RAN from his feelings for Kylie and 'got together' with his old flame? Also I completely agree that Lucas was a dick for keeping that info from her but he asked her to just let him handle it so that they could be together. He asked her not to question it and just trust him. She did and this is what he felt he had to do. Neither of these guys are innocent and the perfect match. If I had to choose between the two, I say Lucas. Yes he wasn't open with her about the details of everything but he seems to have another plan that doesn't include actually marrying the other werewolf. But I would be very happy if she found someone else all together. I think it should be interesting to see what happens in the next book with the entire situation.

I would have to say Derek myself, even though if you look at them individually, they are both pretty stand up guys when it comes to Kylie. I just better feel that Derek understands and accepts Kylie for who she is in her entirety, especially with the ghost whisper abilities. Yes, Derek hooked-up with his old flame, but you have to remember they weren't a couple when this happened, even though it may have hurt like hell. And, yes, Derek has the ability to manipulate feelings, but I don't honestly believe he will do that because he understands where the potential for false love can lead and loves Kylie too much to do something like that to her. Lucas seems to have issues with Kylie not being a full-blooded werewolf, and basically has come out and said just that, Council not withstanding. If you want someone to be something they are not, how can you truly accept them? Not gonna happen, IMHO. I know that Lucas seems confident that once he gets on the Council that he will be able to change things, like get out of his engagement, but I'm not sure he will be able to, and if he does, when? How long will Lucas put Kylie on hold while he fulfills his dreams? I would have to say the best twist would be for Kylie to find another love in the final book of the series.

I think Derek i read all the books and Lucas was just on and off mean or nice, love and hate where as Derek was mostly there for her until she pushed him away

Go Derek

TEAM LUCAS!!!!!!!!!! Since the beginning all the Lucas scenes have touched my heart it so much love between them when Kylie and Derek are more like friendship love and its much more romantic and cute with Kylie and lucas

TEAM LUCAS!!!! I personally like werewolf a better BUT Lucas seems more realistic. Lifes hard. Loves harder. He makes and keeps it real. Love Lucas!!!!

TEAM LUCAS!!!!

I say Lucas was a good choice although i really wanted her to have endde up with with Derek because he really cared about her and understood her, but I understand the fact that Lucas and her have history and that defening of him where they were six made that small bond and she knew sha had something for him.

Lucas all the way! He not only seems hot, but he just sounds like he really love Kylie and I think Derek can find another girl.

TEAM LUCAS!!!
As you can see I think that Lucas is her perfect match.
Even when Lucas did what he did in whispers at moonrise he only did it so he could get on the were council and make Kylie and his love allowed!!!!! Yes he did make some mistakes but he's a boy they all make mistakes.

Lucas because he is so caring and no matter what others believe of him or think that he should do he does what he believes is right and if charming always thinking mostly of others than himself and their security which is what most women or girls would want in their life. He is patient and wants to understand may not be perfect but tries hard to get what he wants. Although influences from family have been important to him in the end it was all up to what and who he really cared for which was Kylie and like in Chosen at Nightfall he never gave up on Kylie and was willing to loose everything for the love of his life, Kylie.

At the beginning of the series I was team Derek. Derek is so sweet and caring toward Kylie. Their relationship was just beginning to really start but Derek was blinded by jealousy. He made a mistake and broke Kylie's heart. Derek blew it. They had a chance but he ruined it. I'm glad they continued to be friends throughout the rest of the series because there is really no one who understands Kylie like Derek! But then there Lucas. Lets be serious Lucas is extremely attractive. Lucas and Kylie were meant to be together. Even though Lucas has his problem and has a hard time accepting Kylie's gifts he is still there for her. Lucas truly cares for her. But after whispers at moonrise I was extremely mad at Lucas! Kylie should of chopped of his werewolf balls for what he did! He betrayed her which was awful! But he still loved her and in the end they were meant for each other. If you have read chosen at nightfall you know what I mean.

Sandra wrote: "Who do you want Kylie to end up with? Why?
who do you like better?
Do you like werewolfs or faes?"
At the beginning of the series I really wanted Kylie to end up with Derek, yes she had a past with Lucas, but accepted her, then I realized who loved her more, who was willing to give everything, the most important things in life for her and then I knew that It was not Derek that I wanted Kylie to end up with but Lucas. The one that would fight for her and wait no matter what, the one who believed that he was doing the right thing and truly loved her.

LUCAS All THE WAY
What are you people thinking I mean seriously Lucas is sweet and passionate.And makes her question every movement. At first I was team Derek but I didn't feel what I feel for Lucas.what I feel for Lucas is something bigger Love❤️ and sure Kyle cares about Derek but if you asked her to choose who would you really think she would save?