.❤YA Lovers❤ discussion

If I Stay (If I Stay, #1)
This topic is about If I Stay
59 views
Series > If I Stay

Comments Showing 1-20 of 20 (20 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Leahxx (last edited Apr 16, 2014 04:06PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Leahxx (heyitsleahxx) | 326 comments Just watched the trailer :) I read this book a looong time ago, but I reread it recently and I love it so much, so they better not frick up this movie.
I have a few problems.
1. Who was in charge of casting because the guy who plays Adam is cute, but not attractive enough to be Adam or not nearly "cool" looking enough. He's cute in a nerdy way, which is NOT how Adam is supposed to be.
2. Idk how I feel about this movie at all, I think it'll be good, but it's a movie that can be easily messed up especially because Hollywood has a talent for ruining books
3. Adam. That's my main problem. I mean what. Why him?

Things I liked-
1. Chloe :) love her, she's a great actress
2. that Teddy was listening to the CD player during the crash, sooo accurate
3. the music, Say Something is such an emotional song and I teared up when it started playing. It was a good choice
4. There are obviously things that come straight out of the book, which is really cute

link: http://youtu.be/2agNeovUjr0


Ally Bryan (allysbookshoparoundthecorner) | 43 comments Watch the trailer for Wish You Were Here with the actor playing Adam in it and it may make you feel better lol! I admit that at times he did not look "hot" at times in the trailer, but I looked him up when he was cast and after watching that trailer I wasn't worried.

I really liked the trailer! I thought that the film itself looked really pretty (the cinematography, etc.) and I like how they chose to do the whole "in limbo" Mia. I loved her parents (they were one of my favorite things about the novel) an that scene where her Dad is holding her as a baby just got to me haha! The song did not help my emotions lol. My main worry for this movie is that critics will be annoying and be all "another YA novel about death...it's just like TFiOS!!". That will seriously drive me insane.


Caru I love the trailer except I think they could have chosen a better actor to play as Adam....I mean he's okay.


Shadowhunter's Library (shadowhunters-library) Even though I am currently reading this book, I LOVED the trailer. I thought it accurately portrayed the book, and it makes me want to see the movie!


message 5: by Maeve, :) (new)

Maeve (echocinderella) | 749 comments Mod
omg it looks amazing


Tayla Potayta (taylapotayta) cannot wait


Leahxx (heyitsleahxx) | 326 comments Saw it last night!! Very good!! Different from the book, obviously, but still very, very good. I like the ending better in the book though
The acting was great. And the actor who plays Adam (Jamie? I forget) was surprisingly good. I thought he did a swell job haha. The emotional level was where I expected it to be.
Such a moving film!


message 8: by Maeve, :) (new)

Maeve (echocinderella) | 749 comments Mod
Wow I just saw it and it was amazing! I cried and cried and cried! :(


It’s.Annie (itsannieeee) | 5 comments I want to watch it don't tell me about it * closes eyes but peeks*


Jayda | 28 comments I'm angry at myself to say that im suprised to hear that it's good. I hope it's what I expect.


Tayla Potayta (taylapotayta) Criiiiiedddd so much


Jayda | 28 comments Was it really similar to the book?


message 13: by It’s.Annie (new) - added it

It’s.Annie (itsannieeee) | 5 comments people said the book is boring is it


Jayda | 28 comments it was pretty good but the sequel is way better. I can honestly see why people would find it a little lacky cause she does ramble around the hospital in sprit form throughout the book. The interesting part of the book are the flashbacks to know how her and adam met and how her family and friends are like.


message 15: by It’s.Annie (new) - added it

It’s.Annie (itsannieeee) | 5 comments okay


onceuponatimeareview | 1265 comments Loved the movie


Veraa (carnaldamage) Still waiting to see the movie :v
I hope it'll be good because there are a lot of people who didnt like it and a lot of who did :p So yeah, i hope i'll enjoy it x)


message 18: by Maeve, :) (new)

Maeve (echocinderella) | 749 comments Mod
Veraa wrote: "Still waiting to see the movie :v
I hope it'll be good because there are a lot of people who didnt like it and a lot of who did :p So yeah, i hope i'll enjoy it x)"


Omg its soooo good


message 19: by Caru (new) - rated it 5 stars

Caru I liked the movie, but not the actor who played as Adam...he was definitely not anything like Adam or how I pictured him.


message 20: by onceuponatimeareview (last edited Nov 21, 2014 05:52PM) (new) - added it

onceuponatimeareview | 1265 comments I didn't read this series yet or anything by Gayle Forman at all :(


back to top