The 5th Wave (The 5th Wave, #1) The 5th Wave discussion


136 views
Book Before Movie?

Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Kylie (new)

Kylie Usually, I am one to always read the books before the movie. But I have had The Fifth Wave sitting on my shelf for months and haven't had the motivation to read it. My brother pretty much told me he hated it. I know it has great reviews and is really popular, but I am kind of leading towards going to see the movie when it comes out and seeing how much i like it.

Is there anyone out there who wants to persuade me to read it before? Is it worth reading before? Opinions? :)


Kyoka Yamamoto I had read the 5th wave and say you that's an awesome book. Better if you read it first before the movie cause as you now books are always better thant movies. Also in the movie can skip important details. Reed the book ma friend ;)


message 3: by Sarah (new) - added it

Sarah Of course! Always read the book first and if you don't like it then you can stop.


Danny Hudson When I started the book I didn't know it was a young adult book, but when I found out I wasn't put off. I really enjoyed it, although there was some soppy teen dialogue in there, but it didn't put me off. I enjoyed it that much, I'm going to read the next book. Having watched the clips from the film, the film seems to detract from the book. Some of the dialogue has swapped characters, some scenes see to be added etc. So, I would read the book first and treat the film as a "based on" book and not a "from book to screen" adaptation.


message 5: by Kylie (new)

Kylie Sarah wrote: "Of course! Always read the book first and if you don't like it then you can stop."

Very true. the problem is that whenever I start a book I pretty much HAVE to finish it. It kinda sucks being that way haha. But I'll give it a try before the movie!


message 6: by Kaz (new) - added it

Kaz But if I read the book first, I'm afraid the movie will have some changes that will disappoint me in the end and will give a bad impression on the whole "The 5th Wave". Does that make any sense?


Stephanie Noel Kylie wrote: "Usually, I am one to always read the books before the movie. But I have had The Fifth Wave sitting on my shelf for months and haven't had the motivation to read it. My brother pretty much told me h..."

Yes read before the movie. Reading the book always helps fill in the blanks that movies that tend to have. Movies leave out many parts or characters that make the book awesome. Plus I love the book. Plus reading a book is cheaper so if you end up not liking it at least you saved money on paying for the movie ticket. They are pricey at times and take up two hours.


Jen! Kaz wrote: "But if I read the book first, I'm afraid the movie will have some changes that will disappoint me in the end and will give a bad impression on the whole "The 5th Wave". Does that make any sense?"

I've read the book and just watched the movie. Having read the book, the film did disappoint me, but, despite the book being a little on the long side, I still think it's worth the read.

I imagine if you don't read the book you may enjoy the film, but the book is more worth it than the film.


message 9: by Emily (last edited Jan 30, 2016 07:34PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Emily The book goes back and forth between present and flashbacks in the front (I haven't gotten very far). I'm sort of reading the book imagining how it would play out in the movie which I don't usually do and I imagine it could be confusing on screen, especially as there's a lot of inner thoughts going on from the main character.
I am also a book before movie person. If you only watch the movie, you don't get the real idea of the book. I am really liking it so far and think the first few chapters are worth trying .


message 10: by Yalda (new)

Yalda I just read the first book and I really wanna watch the movie, should read the other 2 books as well before watching the movie so I won’t get anything spoiled?


Layla Yalda wrote: "I just read the first book and I really wanna watch the movie, should read the other 2 books as well before watching the movie so I won’t get anything spoiled?"
I've read all the books and watched the movie and movie doesn't spoil anything from the other books it's just for the first one.


message 12: by Owen (last edited Jan 12, 2021 01:09AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Owen Davies no, that movie was awful, then again I thought the book was okay but very entertaining. and had nice characters.


message 13: by eve (new) - rated it 4 stars

eve Read it. Just the first one though. I haven't watched the movie yet. Should I?


Kaydence I'd definitely read the book first. Although the movie had portrayed some of the scenes in the novel, and the overall plot, I'd consider these two completely different stories. The characters had been lost in translation in the movie. For example, I 100% believe they dumbed down the main character into a damsel in distress. Also, it's not as thrilling as the novel, I had watched this with my brothers, who had not read the book, and they said the movie was very predictable and they weren't really surprised with it. They had taken out big scenes and the visuals didn't do the novel justice. I'd 100% recommend reading the book before the movie. But, I'm gonna be honest, the book wasn't the best thing to read.


message 15: by Mimi (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mimi Lopes Anna wrote: "Read it. Just the first one though. I haven't watched the movie yet. Should I?"
Don't, its so bad and it ruined the book for me. I regret watching it.


back to top