Fledgling
question
Unsure about this novel - Merits and drawbacks, anyone?

Last night, I started Fledging - still very much in the beginning, but forget what page exactly. However, when I put down this book, my stomach was roiling.
Bluntly, I've read a lot of weird shit, being a SFF aficionado - but this, this makes me a little sick, and I was so anxious to do a deep dive into Butler after flying through Parable of the Sower and Parable of the Talents.
Can anyone speak to the merits of this work? The body of a 10 year old girl having graphic sex with a man in his 20s is . . . not what I was expecting. I don't care if the 10 year old body is housing an older mind and sentient wisdom - it almost just sounds like pedophile fodder.
Bluntly, I've read a lot of weird shit, being a SFF aficionado - but this, this makes me a little sick, and I was so anxious to do a deep dive into Butler after flying through Parable of the Sower and Parable of the Talents.
Can anyone speak to the merits of this work? The body of a 10 year old girl having graphic sex with a man in his 20s is . . . not what I was expecting. I don't care if the 10 year old body is housing an older mind and sentient wisdom - it almost just sounds like pedophile fodder.
reply
flag
Yeah, that bit skeeved me out too. Butler gives us a few hints as to what is really going on there, but just so as to allay your concerns, (view spoiler) . So, she's kind of flipping the script on that one a bit.
Vampire/victim age discrepancies always give me pause. Hopefully, you'll not find a (view spoiler) -year-old having sex with a man in his twenties as creepy.
I read this book as part of the GR bookclub I'm in,
Sci-Fi & Fantasy Girlz, so for a fuller discussion have a look at: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
Vampire/victim age discrepancies always give me pause. Hopefully, you'll not find a (view spoiler) -year-old having sex with a man in his twenties as creepy.
I read this book as part of the GR bookclub I'm in,
Sci-Fi & Fantasy Girlz, so for a fuller discussion have a look at: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
View all 4 comments
This is far from Butler's best work.
I'm nevertheless fond of the book because I like reading her but often find the nasty stuff in her books overwhelming. There's no apocalypse in Fledgling, people don't tear each other into pieces over scraps and instead of the patriarchal sociopaths she loves to write about, you get to read about people who actually care for each other.
I don't think it makes a difference how old the vampire child actually is.
What does make a difference is that this child is a man-eating monster who uses mind-control drug on her sexual partners. She's not a victim but the predator.
This SO not like pedophilia!
Many read the book as a power/sex fantasy and/or as a revenge fantasy: the reader projects themself (or their younger self) in a character who looks like someone who might be a victim but actually hurts and kills people, does whatever she likes and has sex with whoever she feels like.
I'm nevertheless fond of the book because I like reading her but often find the nasty stuff in her books overwhelming. There's no apocalypse in Fledgling, people don't tear each other into pieces over scraps and instead of the patriarchal sociopaths she loves to write about, you get to read about people who actually care for each other.
I don't think it makes a difference how old the vampire child actually is.
What does make a difference is that this child is a man-eating monster who uses mind-control drug on her sexual partners. She's not a victim but the predator.
This SO not like pedophilia!
Many read the book as a power/sex fantasy and/or as a revenge fantasy: the reader projects themself (or their younger self) in a character who looks like someone who might be a victim but actually hurts and kills people, does whatever she likes and has sex with whoever she feels like.
J_Jens
This is actually a good review that sums my opinion up: https://rhapsodyinbooks.wordpress.com...
...more
· flag
· flag
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic