All About YA discussion

So Robin noticed that there wasn't a place for members to discuss books, so we are starting a few topics for you.

Discuss If I Stay here.

I just finished If I Stay yesterday, and I did like it, but I didn't LOVE it, you know?

I loved both of these books. I loved Where She Went even MORE than If I Stay, which is amazing.

I loved both books, but I think I liked Where She Went more.

Loved both. But agree the second one was the best. Loved the ending.

Kyla wrote: "I just finished If I Stay yesterday, and I did like it, but I didn't LOVE it, you know?"

Have you read the sequel? It's really good.

Becca wrote: "Loved both. But agree the second one was the best. Loved the ending."

Erin wrote: "I loved both books, but I think I liked Where She Went more."

I love how the relationship develops in Where She Went and I love the contrast of all the band stuff compared to Mia's life in Where She Went. I love that both of the books (obviously) take place at different points in Mia and Adam's lives.

And I loved the flasbacks so much.

Georgia wrote: "Just finished If i stay and currently reading where she went :)"

How did you like If I Stay?

Georgia wrote: "It was good, i was a little let down by it but not by much. I hope Where she went is better, a lot of you seem to think it is :)"

I loved Where She Went. If I had to truly rate them, If I Stay would be five stars, but Where She Went would be six.

Georgia wrote: "I just finished Where She Went. I liked it a lot, it was definitely better than If I stay."

Yay yay yay. It's sort of rare for a sequel to live up to it's predecessor, but this one really did! I loved exploring Adam's character and everything. It was just so great! It's definitely one of my favorite books.

I loved If I Stay, but didn't really like Where She Went

Georgia wrote: "I just finished Where She Went. I liked it a lot, it was definitely better than If I stay."

Amber wrote: "Georgia wrote: "I just finished Where She Went. I liked it a lot, it was definitely better than If I stay."

Yay yay yay. It's sort of rare for a sequel to live up to it's predecessor, but this one..."

same!

Erin wrote: "Georgia wrote: "It was good, i was a little let down by it but not by much. I hope Where she went is better, a lot of you seem to think it is :)"

I loved Where She Went. If I had to truly rate the..."

lol. :D