Support for Indie Authors discussion
Archived Author Help
>
Who can honestly say they are making regular profit on book sales and if so how do you do it?
date
newest »


I understand some people strive to become full-time writers and thus live from their royalties but... That requires a lot of hard work and in the first couple of years, at least, I think it's quite unachievable.
When you're starting off as an author, until you've created a base of fans and dedicated readers who are willing to buy your books or support you via any other means, then yes, your best tools are free promotions and Kindle Unlimited.
There's nothing really wrong with that. If you add your book in KU you're not losing anything so to speak. You're giving readers a chance to experiment your work and decide whether they should buy it or not. People who really enjoy your book will buy it to support you even if they've read it on KU already.
And, hey, if you look at it this way, that's double the income, right? Or as close to it as possible.
Pile that with throwing in a bunch of ARCs to reviewers to create a bit of a buzz around your book and in terms of free advertising, that's about it. If you want something more elaborate, you can always try paid advertising and see where that takes you.
But honestly, so far, at least for me, KU has proved to be quite an useful tool. Most of my royalties come from KU. Besides, you can put to use the promotional tools KDP provides.
That's your best option as a new author, honestly. Join book release events, create a network of contacts, reach out to bloggers and from time to time, do offer free promotions and free books. Readers need to familiarise themselves with your work first to decide whether it's something they'd enjoy or not. There's really no other way around it as an indie author.
Promoting a book is a lot of hard work and not a lot of money :). But it all boils down to the reason why you're writing after all.
Hope that helps.

Thank you for your reply. I shall take note of everything that you said. If you don't mind could you answer another couple of questions for me please?
What are ARC's? And which reviewers would you recommend? Also with regards to Kindle Unlimited, which sites are the best to direct people to there? I agree with you that writing is about more than just making money. That does go without saying. But it is always a thought in the background. Thank you again.


When it comes to recommending reviewers, to be honest, I've tried both reaching out to readers in Facebook groups and to bloggers. From experience I can tell you to prepare yourself for a couple of disappointments. That's one thing I learnt. Not all of the people who say they will review your book will end up doing that. And that's fine, because next time you'll know who to approach, so in my case, I'll be sticking to blogs mostly and people I know to be reliable. Keep in mind that giving away a free copy doesn't guarantee a positive review and quite frankly, it shouldn't. The reviewer should feel free to say their opinion about your book, no matter what that opinion is.
From my point of view critique is something that will help you move forward as an author and realize what you're doing wrong.
Obviously, the genre you write in should give you an idea about your readers and the best approach to take in that case.
And when it comes to directing people to KU, social media in general is a great tool to do that. Facebook, Twitter, Goodreads in the groups that allow you to create self-promo threads and so on. Basically, any platform will do. But it's really important to identify those groups you want to cater to. Usually on Facebook you find hundreds of groups of just about everything, so it's easier to start there. At least it was for me.
Wish you good luck! :D

Thank you D I'll be sure to check out those websites.

First of all, I agree with this 100% There are much easier ways to make extra cash. Writing a book is a job. Being a full time author is several full time jobs in one and unless you are really lucky, you aren't going to make what works out to minimum wage when you factor in everything you need to do.
Second, free books and KU are in fact, how I've turned a steady profit on my books for six years running. Well, KU for 3 of those years since the KOLL wasn't nearly as profitable, though it was nice.
Note: turning a profit and making a living are two different things. I spent 4 years writing for a living and while I always turned a profit, I occasionally had to dip into savings to continue "living."
Free books lead to sales. I won't go into this here because I've spoken exhaustively about this on the promo thread and you're welcome to read that. But I think both of you are misinformed about KU. When someone downloads a book through KU and reads it, the author is paid for the pages read. It's not a way for readers to "try" a book, but rather a way to read as many books as they can for one flat monthly rate.
As to how I do this profitably, I don't spend tons of money on things like advice, full price advertising, or expensive software. I do spend time setting up promotions so that I've always got something out there and my name doesn't fall into obscurity. I also have several completed series, which means I have box set options as an alternative to buying each book separately.
I do need to state that having a steady release schedule has helped, as has the fact that my first book came out when KDP was still pretty new. Mine was one of nearly 1 million books available (in Kindle format) at the time. Today that number is closer to 6 million and growing exponentially, so yes, it is much tougher to get that initial exposure these days.
This past year, I stopped writing as a full time job and yes, the lack of time spent maintaining my book promos has definitely taken its toll on the amount of royalties I'm making, but I've yet to see anything dry up, mainly thanks to KU.

The best advice I can give is to keep writing. Your next book is your best marketing.
I have a blog and a website. I am on Twitter and Facebook. But I can't honestly say they are the key.
All I know is that I somehow found an audience.
Keep writing. Write what you like to read. Join a writers group. Attend conferences. And most of all Enjoy it!


But, once you dive in and actually write for the enjoyment, I think your chances of actually doing better work improve. I know the quality of my second work was better than the first, and part of that was due to me focusing on the story.
I have had others tell me that social media is vital for promoting your books. That's tough for me as I'm not a social media kind of guy, plus I'm a bit of a crank. I have run some book promos. Freebooksy (IIRC) worked out well. An ad on my favorite (non-literary) blog turned a small profit, as did one other book promo site whose name escapes me right now.
Finding people to give ARC's to, in exchange for reviews (and I genuinely want honest reviews) does seem to be a challenge.
I will give you this- there is a real delight in checking in to Amazon or Goodreads and finding that someone, somewhere has given you a real nice review. That's a treat.

Thank you so much for all this advice. I really appreciate it. I don't suppose you could give me the links to any bloggers you would recommend. I think when I'm ready that's where I might start.

Hi Alex thank you for joining this discussion. If you don't mind me asking what is this paid advertising site you are using, and how much are you having to pay? I have looked into this myself, and so far I can't tell which ones would be worth trying. Also with releasing multiple books, do you mainly concentrate on the latest book, hoping it will be enough to attract people to the others, or do you return to advertising any of the earlier books at any time?

The best advice I can give is to keep writing. Your nex..."
Hi Martin thank you for your feedback. You say to keep writing, that your next book is your best marketing. I imagine that is the case, but how do you split your time between marketing and writing? Do you do a little bit of both everyday, or do you write for an allotted amount of days and then stop every so often to check in with some marketing. I'd really be interested to know.
Seth wrote: "I don't suppose you could give me the links to any bloggers you would recommend."
If anyone wants to PM Seth with links, they are welcome. Please don't post the links here. Thanks.
If anyone wants to PM Seth with links, they are welcome. Please don't post the links here. Thanks.

First of all, I agree with this 100% There are much easier ways to make extra cash. Writing a book..."
Thank you for this Christina. This is all very helpful information.

What is the subject you are writing about? If you look the genre up on google and search for reviewers, you'll find entire pages with results. :P

Hi, I use BargainBook..."
Hi Alex,
For BargainBooksy, have you ever used (or has anyone else for that matter) the New Release promo? It's not cheap, but I'm wondering if there's been a good conversion rate or not on these promos?

I'm not there yet but inching closer. I know some people who are. You can find them on Facebook at 20booksto50k (odd title, I know) There are about 25,000 members, all authors. Many of them post their amazon payments on the page. While you cannot promote your books on the page, you can ask pretty much any question and receive honest answers. They are happy to share and don't charge anything. Try it.
Steve Peek

Hi, I use BargainBook..."
Thanks for that Alex. So you advertise with Bargain Booksy for $55 a month. I noticed that you are from the UK. Does your bank not charge you overseas transaction fees for the conversion rate? This is one of the worries that puts me off trying international websites. Also how long after first advertising with Bargain Booksy did you notice an increase in sales, and how significant was it?

What is the subject you are writing about? If you look the genre ..."
That's no problem Alexander. I'm currently writing a thriller. I have tried googling the genre and have found many bloggers, but the first hand experience of others who have used them is what I'm looking for, so I don't waste my time with the wrong ones. Thank you again.

Hi, I use BargainBook..."
Alex, you are AWESOME!!! Thanks so much for the info you have provided for us newbie indies!!!! I just published in September and am learning things to do a bit differently with my next book to be released in January. I've been a little disappointed in my sales but most have come from word of mouth/social media exposure. You have given me some hope as I was looking into possibly doing some paid advertising!!! Thanks again, Shanna :-)

But, once you dive in and actually write..."
Hi Bill, thanks for joining the discussion. I'm not a social media kind of guy either. I do not have a Facebook or twitter account, or any of the others. I am constantly being told to open them though by other writers. The truth is I have a feeling that it won't work for me like it does for other people. I'm not particularly sociable. One of my main reasons for not wanting to open a Facebook account is that I don't want people from my past to be able to find and contact me. And even if I did start a Facebook account under a pseudonym I really don't like the idea of starting with 0 friends and having to build a friend base up from scratch, doing something that is very unnatural to me. Having said that though, I probably wouldn't have dreamed of starting a discussion like this one, so perhaps I may try the social media thing yet.

You will probably hear this incessantly, but making money through writing fiction is extraordinarily difficult in this day and age. If you choose to write, do it because you are passionate about your work and you have something to say. Here are some thoughts in no particular order.
1. When you ask yourself, "Am I making money," it's not enough to factor in the costs of editing, advertising, covers and marketing. You have to weigh the opportunity cost as well. In other words, if you spent 500 hours writing a novel, how much money could you have made elsewhere with a part-time job?
2. I don't know these figures exactly, but I believe there are approximately 4.8 million books for sale in the Kindle store, with more than 100,000 new English-language novels published every year. So, yeah, there's a little bit of competition out there. I wish I knew who to attribute this quote to, but some say "Thanks to self-publishing there are now more writers than readers." A bit of hyperbole, but a bit of truth.
3. Upon publishing your book, you will HAVE to spend money for advertising and marketing. It is a learning process and too much for this discussion, but as always, you will have to spend a little money to make money.
4. When you see all the books for sale on Amazon, check out their sales ranking in the Kindle store. Anything approximating "100,000" means they are selling one E-book per day. "50,000" is 5 or 6. You will be surprised by books that sell and books that don't.
5. If you really want to make money, pay heed to genres. There are themes that sell and things that don't. Literary fiction is especially an uphill battle.
6. You are competing with Netflix, Youtube, Play Station, Instagram, and a zillion other electronic entertainment choices. People are reading less and less, especially men. I think the current figure is 80% of fiction is purchased by women these days.
7. You will hear the "five book" rule tossed around. Many authors say that somewhere around their fifth book, something kicked in, and they "got it." They started writing better books, they got better at marketing, they started selling more books, and began making real money.
Anyway, that's a lot of yammering, but I hope some of it was helpful. Write because you love it and you have something to say. And plenty of people do make money doing it, so why not you?

Writing for you, your love for writing, and because you have something to say is so very important. Making money for what you love would be awesome, too.
I’ve only published one book. I’ve done great with free downloads, probably over 10,000 copies, but have not made a profit after all the advertising costs. I rarely get kindle or paperback sales now. I think it’s true that once you write more books, you start seeing more sales. I’m working on the sequel to my debut, not just for that reason, but because readers that loved my book have convinced me to. And I love writing, and my story and message behind the to-be series. If I make money off this series, wohoo! If not, then I’m still happy that I’ve drawn a particular fan group that truly get my message and love living in the world I created!
Good luck!
I'm not exactly swimming in my profits, but I am making profits. What I do seems to go against all advice I've heard since I discovered self-publishing.
I don't write in popular genres. I don't write series (not in the sense people often mean it today). I strive to write stuff that few to no one is writing these days. It's taken some time, but I'm finally seeing sales and downloads on a regular basis.
It seems the less marketing I do, the more activity I see. I have no idea why it works that way, but it does.
The only thing I can think is that I spend a great deal of time striving to write the kind of stories that will stick with readers for a long time. I also have a lot of short stories out there and make one or two free now and then. That nearly always gives my sales a little boost.
Again. I'm not getting wealthy from this. I have yet to be able to quit my day job. But, a profit is a profit and it grows, ever so slightly. I'm fine with it. I never expected to make a living at this.
I don't write in popular genres. I don't write series (not in the sense people often mean it today). I strive to write stuff that few to no one is writing these days. It's taken some time, but I'm finally seeing sales and downloads on a regular basis.
It seems the less marketing I do, the more activity I see. I have no idea why it works that way, but it does.
The only thing I can think is that I spend a great deal of time striving to write the kind of stories that will stick with readers for a long time. I also have a lot of short stories out there and make one or two free now and then. That nearly always gives my sales a little boost.
Again. I'm not getting wealthy from this. I have yet to be able to quit my day job. But, a profit is a profit and it grows, ever so slightly. I'm fine with it. I never expected to make a living at this.
Leah wrote: "I wish there were a LIKE button for James’ comment. ❤️ "
So you did what writers do. You wrote out "I like James' comment" (more or less) which takes more time than to press a button which means more.
So you did what writers do. You wrote out "I like James' comment" (more or less) which takes more time than to press a button which means more.

My second novel was a psychological thriller, and I self-published it for very low cost, doing everything myself. Somehow or other I managed to get lucky and it stayed in the top 100 of one of its categories on amazon UK for months, and for about 3 months I made UK full time minimum wage purely on ebook sales and KU reads of that one book. It was a really exciting time, and gave me a boost. It eventually dropped out of the top 100, and I wasn't able to replicate this success with my third book, another psychological thriller.
Nowadays, I spend out money on advertising on amazon.com using their AMS ads, and in the UK (where AMS ads aren't available yet) I use facebook ads, which I've found reasonably effective at selling ebooks and paperbacks. I'm planning on doing some work soon on improving my targeting and adding video adverts on facebook to hopefully improve their performance. The amount I spend on these ads is a bit scary, but when I work it out against my royalties, I am making a profit, largely due to KU reads.
I am now in the process of finishing two sequels to my second book, (which has been my most commercially successful to date), and then running free promotions on the first book in the series. This often seems to be the advice that authors give - having a series and offering the first book for free every now and again - so I was keen to have a series, plus I always felt I had unfinished business with the characters from the first book so I enjoyed spending more time with them.
When you start getting more sales, some other opportunities could start popping up. I signed a contract for the audio rights to one of my books earlier this year, and have been approached by a traditional publisher.
Facebook has been hugely useful to me, as I am involved in a book club where a lot of the readers enjoy my genre.
I am definitely aiming to make a living from writing if I possibly can - I have a lot of health problems that make it hard for me to do a "normal" job, so writing actually feels like one of the only ways I can contribute to my family's income. I think overall this year I may end up not making much profit as I'll have paid for editing and cover design for my new series, and there'll be a bit of a delay before I get that money back. I'm optimistic that it will work out ok once the books are released. Fingers crossed!
By the way, I noticed you asked about banks charging for overseas transactions if you live in the UK. My bank has charged me for purchases in USD, so yes, this is something to take into consideration. You can get credit cards that don't charge for overseas transactions. There may be other ways round it as well.
Hope some of that is helpful! To be honest, marketing sometimes feels like trial and error, and hoping for a bit of luck now and then. But it's a good idea to follow discussions about marketing, do some research of your own, and accept that it might take some time (and unfortunately some money too!)


The biggest and easiest is of course letting folks know you wrote a book. I'm not suggesting you view friends and family as customers (actually, I'm suggesting the opposite, don't sell to them), but usually when you accomplish something big like publishing a book, folks will be happy for you. They might spread the word and they might even buy a copy even if that have no intention of reading because well, friends are nice people sometimes. This could help give you a boost.
There are also sites that promote new release books that don't charge anything. Some of these have a huge KU user following, so that too is an instant boost.
My advice (with the caveat that your milage may vary) would be to spend nothing in your first year of publishing. Once you've discovered how much you've made, use that amount to set your advertising budget for the next year. And of course, keep writing. Like Martin said above, your next book is your best advertising.

You will probably hear this incessantly, but making money through writing fiction is extraordinarily difficult in this day and age. If you choose to write, do it because you are passionate..."
Dwayne wrote: "I'm not exactly swimming in my profits, but I am making profits. What I do seems to go against all advice I've heard since I discovered self-publishing.
I don't write in popular genres. I don't w..."
L.K. wrote: "I just want to add, I found it completely bewildering when I started out with self-publishing. I remember I joined this group not too long after publishing my first book, about four years ago now, ..."
Christina wrote: "One thing to keep in mind: the more money you spend, the less you profit. It seems like a no brainier, but I see new authors pouring tons into marketing of a book when it's not yet needed. Your fir..."
Thank you everyone for your feedback so far. This is really great stuff. I feel like I'm already off to a good start, knowing all this.

Hi L.K, thank you for your feedback so far. I was just wondering how you got on with using Good Reads forums for advertising. I would probably consider starting there since it won't cost me anything? I was wondering if when it came to it, I would be able to cut and paste the same ads into several different forums. I've noticed that some forums seem to dislike this approach, and prefer you to take the time to get to know everyone there before you consider posting any ads. What has your experience been?

Others may well have different experiences to mine though :)

@Seth, I pay using Paypal so no transaction fees to worry ab..."
Yes, thank you Alex, you have explained it all very well. I'm sure this information will be of great use to me.

You will probably hear this incessantly, but making money through writing fiction is extraordinarily difficult in this day and age. If you choose to write, do it because you are passionate..."
Alexander wrote: "Seth, I wouldn't actually be able to do that for one simple reason. I write MM romance and I look for reviewers only in that genre.
What is the subject you are writing about? If you look the genre ..."
Dwayne wrote: "I'm not exactly swimming in my profits, but I am making profits. What I do seems to go against all advice I've heard since I discovered self-publishing.
I don't write in popular genres. I don't w..."
L.K. wrote: "I just want to add, I found it completely bewildering when I started out with self-publishing. I remember I joined this group not too long after publishing my first book, about four years ago now, ..."
Christina wrote: "One thing to keep in mind: the more money you spend, the less you profit. It seems like a no brainier, but I see new authors pouring tons into marketing of a book when it's not yet needed. Your fir..."
Alex wrote: "@Jessica, no, I haven't used the New Release feature, the price has put me off because the odds of making back the cost has put me off.
@Seth, I pay using Paypal so no transaction fees to worry ab..."
One thing that has me very curious is how does everyone get on with sales at Christmas? I imagine there aren't as many people buying e books as there are physical copies, since you can hardly give them as a gift. And what kind of promotions could you do if your book was already free?

There's a promotion info folder with tons of useful information about promotion, including a thread where folks have shared their stats.

I don't write in popular genres. I don't w..."
Hi Dwayne, I suspect you will eventually become the most successful author in this string. What author name do you use on Amazon. I'm going to buy one of your books. Steve Peek
I would tell you, Steve, but that would be self-promotion and I'd have to remove my own comment. *chuckle*

Hmmm, Silly rule. I asked your author name in order to find one of your books. Seems overly strict to me. Of course, I'm old enough most rules that have nothing with holding civilization's fabric together seem pointless.
I was interested in reading one of your books because of some of the things you said about breaking the rules of self-publishing. I spent forty years working in the toy and game industry. The one thing I learned was that the really big, blockbuster ideas never came from the big toy companies. They ALWAYS came from individuals who ignored what they had to do to succeed.
Anyway, thought I'd try to find one of your books.

Without it, this place would be nothing but authors spamming the hell out of us without contributing anything worthwhile to the conversation (which is why the rules was implemented in the first place), however, you can very easily find Dwayne's books by clicking in his name.

Writing the first book, in my opinion, should be done because a person has a story and wants to share it whether it garnishes profit or not. With experience and improved storytelling, profit will no doubt follow, while the next step of writing as a full time job is another issue. I have a friend who is a full-time writer, recently made a significant profit, but to do so traveled a fair amount in promoting the book.
In addition, local book stores, libraries, local media could all be avenues for self-promotion of a book - start small and branch out.
Hope this is helpful.
Steve wrote: "Hmmm, Silly rule."
Since the focus on the group is for us to help one another with advice and whatnot, and not to be trying to sell our books to each other, the rule is necessary.
I figured you were joking anyway, since it's not that hard to track down someone's books from here. I've done it many times. And just in case you weren't joking, I sent you a PM with my name shortly after I responded to your post.
Anyway. My way of thinking is similar to your example of the toy industry. Most of my favorite authors did not get where they got by doing what everyone else is doing.
Since the focus on the group is for us to help one another with advice and whatnot, and not to be trying to sell our books to each other, the rule is necessary.
I figured you were joking anyway, since it's not that hard to track down someone's books from here. I've done it many times. And just in case you weren't joking, I sent you a PM with my name shortly after I responded to your post.
Anyway. My way of thinking is similar to your example of the toy industry. Most of my favorite authors did not get where they got by doing what everyone else is doing.

On the question of promotion and advertising, I have followed the concept of trying to find places that work for me. That means checking up the sites you are going to use - most of them simply don't work, but when you find one that does lead to sales, use it. I am afraid it is trial and error, and you will probably lose out to begin with, but one clue is to check the sites you are thinking of, and if they spend most of their space on genres alien to your writing, it will be a waste of time and money using them.

Hi Christina I was just looking over messages from yesterday to compile everything useful to form a plan of action, and I saw what you said about paying nothing in the first year. This would be my plan, but looking around I can't seem to find much that you can do for free. All I know of so far is using the Good Reads forums to post ads. Could you please point me in the direction of these sites that promote new release books for free that you mentioned. Thank you.

I don't mean to be rude, but I have been through many forums for information on how best to advertise your book, but most of the advice I find is for free books or those on kindle unlimited. In the end let's all be honest, authors want to sell books for money and make a profit. What I'd really like to know, is who is actually managing to do that? And if so, how? I haven't written anything myself yet to be published. I plan to, but before I do I want to compile as much information as I can find. All I know so far is that friends of mine have tried and failed. So I'd really like some advice from people who are actually making it work.