Star Wars Bookworms Book Club discussion
September 2014 Book- A New Dawn
>
Greetings from JJM
date
newest »

John thank you so much from Aaron and Myself for joining. The book club does pretty well and we are excited to start the new Star Wars literary world off with a bang! We look forward to any time you can give In furthering discussions.
Again thank you so much and may the force be with you!
Again thank you so much and may the force be with you!

JJM's acknowledgement of all Star Wars authors at the beginning of A New Dawn offers a sensible way of thinking about the old and new canon. There's no need to grieve or lament like the loss of a loved one. Those past stories can sit on your shelf forever and just like an old friend, you can visit them any time you want.

I'm new here and really glad I found the podcast and group, thanks Aaron and Teresa.
Darren really liked that line too and I agree with you. The Star Wars fan in me did grieve a little at first but the comics fan thought "What is this canon you speak of?".


My notes for A New Dawn will follow later in the fall.



John, thanks for kicking off the canon with a bang!
I do have a musing, though....
I enjoy 'A New Dawn' very much. I have to ask, does anyone else have to think of Dr. Strangelove when reading Vidian's lines?
What kind of voice did you 'hear' for him in your head, John - if the question is allowed.
Regards
Chris



I loved A New Dawn and thought that you opened the new cannon with a beautiful succession of bangs (literally, thanks to Skelly!).
I guess if I had a question, it would be about the inclusion of "real world" concerns such as environmental destruction and government/corporate privacy invasion. On the one hand, these issues grounded the story and gave it an air of reality. But on the other hand, you run the risk of taking a reader out of the fantasy and reminding them that these are specific and concrete threats in their own lives.
For what it's worth, I think you walk that line beautifully, but I guess I'd like to hear what your take is on how you go about including specific real-world concerns without sounding preachy or overly topical. There were times in the prequels when it felt like George was preaching in a way that it never felt in the OT, but I'm not sure I can put my finger on why that is.
PS: The fate of the Lals hit me really hard. Well done.
Don't know how often I'll get in here given my schedule, but I should be able to help with any burning questions. :-)