To All the Boys I've Loved Before (To All the Boys I've Loved Before, #1) To All the Boys I've Loved Before discussion


167 views
team peter or team john?

Comments Showing 1-33 of 33 (33 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

inayah peter for sure


Thora-Lee John is cute, but team Peter always.


message 3: by lo (new) - rated it 5 stars

lo john tbh


inayah loore :) wrote: "john tbh"

noo


Emma (Taylor's version) Peter alwaysssssssss


inayah Emma (Taylor's version) wrote: "Peter alwaysssssssss"

AGREED


Pen&Quill  Read loore :) wrote: "john tbh"

I'm with you, Peter may be great but if I'm picking for me.. I'm going with John. Hands down. I mean USO night!! Come on.

– Quill


laila :) gosh a question that haunts me when i can’t sleep!! i think yes always Peter but it would’ve been so nice to see what would’ve happened if LJ and John ended up together :)


message 9: by Eni (new) - rated it 4 stars

Eni S.E. Team Peter because they work better together, and because I want John for myself hehe


Pen&Quill  Read Eni wrote: "Team Peter because they work better together, and because I want John for myself hehe"

Yes!


Princess Peter definitely!!!!!


Bella peter's hotter and more popular, but his obsession with Genevive and the fact that he is willing to cheat on Lara Jean with her is sort of a red flag. I know this is kind of an unpopular opinion, but I think Team John! He genuinely cares about Lara Jean and he is kind. I feel like he wouldn't hurt her the way Peter has.


poppy 🪼 peter 100% but i value johns friendship lmao


Nerea's Library In the books Peter all the way.
But in the movie thay paint Peter a lot worst, and John as her true soulmate, it was really weird because the two actors seemed to have a really good chemistry and I loved their relationship way more . It felt like they were really happy while working toghether and seemed like a better match.
Anyone else thought it was weird??


Cristina Atkins Peter for sure!!!


message 16: by Ruby (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ruby John Ambrose all the way.


musicaldemigod Peter for LJ, John for me 😋


Hannah Peter for sure, but John Ambrose is cute :)


Marielle Isnt his name Josh?


message 20: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa BAETZ Neither. Team Josh!


message 21: by (last edited Oct 13, 2023 10:13PM) (new)

✰ john ambrose!


Evelyn Shaw Peter was so so loving in the book but he did show a lot of red flags for LJ. Personally, I would have gone with John because he was just sooooooo original and sweet. And she's, like, best friends with his grandma so it's a total plus and a half


message 23: by rae (new) - rated it 5 stars

rae Peter. There is no other option.
Question 1. Peter or John?
A. Peter
B. Peter
C. Peter
D. Peter


Faith Marshall John Ambrose. He seemed so kind and caring and honest, like a true gentleman. Peter could be sweet, but whenever he did something thoughtful, it was misunderstood, and he didn't explain until Lara Jean was mad or upset or doubting him, and then he was mad. John Ambrose is my sort of guy <3


Faith Marshall Evelyn wrote: "Peter was so so loving in the book but he did show a lot of red flags for LJ. Personally, I would have gone with John because he was just sooooooo original and sweet. And she's, like, best friends ..."

Haha, yes!


Faizah M musicaldemigod wrote: "Peter for LJ, John for me 😋"


legit me...


Vaiga Peterr omg💓


Palak A man or a boy?


Millie Younker Definitely team peter 100%


Tasha team peter for sure:)


Aydin peter always he was so sweet


Arohi PETER


message 33: by Aurora Jade (AJ) (last edited Sep 05, 2025 04:27PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Aurora Jade (AJ) ALWAYS AND FOREVER....PETER! Not gonna lie I also like movie Peter. Maybe more than book Peter to be honest.


back to top