2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #2 discussion

They learn from fingerprints on the stolen jewelry that Harper Scott is really Sara Harper, a young woman from Scarlet Falls with a record. She’s also Sariah Scott, Eli’s “girlfriend.” The body they found was also identified as Brian O’Neil, one of Eli’s roommates. At this point, did you think either one of them was still alive?

No, at this point, I figured they were both dead.

I agree. That is when I assumed both Harper (Sara) and Eli were dead.

I had already guessed by this point that Sariah and Harper were one and the same, and that she was probably killed when Alyssa heard the shot and saw the killer.

I also suspected that Eli was dead but I wanted it to be otherwise for his poor grandmother.

I was holding out hope for Eli’s grandmother but things looked grim. I suspected that Harper was Sariah but the curve ball was her being Sara Harper. It was a little sketchy given how small these communities are for no one to catch on.