The 52 Book Club: 2025 Challenge discussion
Check-In
>
Week 3 - January 15, 2023
This is my 6th year in The 52 Book Club, in previous years I've tried to only use diverse/of colour authors, and one year I did the challenge both in novels and in picture books. I don't do the challenge in order, I don't limit myself to one book a week, I'm definitely going to read 52 books plus the ones for the mini challenges, I do a little planning but I mostly just mood read and see what fits where. Once I fit a book into a prompt I don't move it around later. I'm doing a couple other Storygraph challenges, but this is my main focus.
My personal goals are just to use more books that I own.
My personal goals are just to use more books that I own.


Prompt 1 Churchill's Secret Messenger: A Ww2 Novel of Spies & the French Resistance by Alan Hlad
Prompt #2 The Widows of Malabar Hill by Sujata Massey
Prompt #3 The Greatest Company In The World? The Story Of Tataby Peter Casey by
Prompt #4 Hotel du Lac by Anita Brookner
Prompt #5 If Beale Street Could Talk by James Baldwin
Prompt #6 Foster by Claire Keegan
Not sure if I will be able to do all 52 in order but I am starting this way. I may have to switch books later in case I cannot fit the prompts.
Finally I have a very ambitious goal of reading two books per prompt and making one nonfiction. I am pretty sure some of the prompts will not allow for this, though so far I have found books for these first six prompts.


I am trying not to move things around, once placed in a prompt I want it to stay. Last year I moved around a lot, now I am also trying to complete an older 52 challenge so books that don't fit can go into that or a different challenge.

- Are you completing the challenge in order?
No
- Are you limiting yourself to one book a week?
No
- Is your goal to complete all 52 books? 26 books? All the mini-challenges too?
I’d like to fill all 52 prompts but I’m not sure I will. There are just some categories that don’t interest me at all. I know part of the idea is to broaden what I read, but we’ll see if I actually choose to complete each prompt. Not sure about the mini-challenges.
- Are you only reading specific authors or genres?
No
- Working through previous 52 Book Club challenges? Or other outside challenges?
I am also doing the Better World Books challenge.
- Planned it out exactly? Reading and filling in prompts as you go along?
I’m reading what I want, then figuring out which prompts each book might fill.
- Only using books you already own?
So far, yes, but not necessarily.
- Are you letting yourself move books around throughout the year? Or once you match it to a prompt are you locking it in?
I am very open to moving things around. In my own separate spreadsheet, I am marking all the prompts each book meets and will finalize at the end of the year.

My only special rule is that I am not buying any books - just using my library and any books people may give me.
I created my own spreadsheet and took notes on titles from others in the Club to give me ideas on some of the books I may read to fit the prompts and I have noticed that many are classics that I have never read before so this gives me something to look forward to as well.



-the prompts listed on the first column and a Book planned and Book Read with start and finish dates finish dates , format, owned or not owned and star rating
-books listed on the first column and the prompts as headers across the columns. This allows me to select which prompt I choose, make recommendations and move later if needed.
When the prompts were released, I used the Goodreads Masterlist to find unread books on my bookshelf for almost every prompt and hope to use 70% of the books from my bookshelves
Last year I completed all of the Mini-Challenges and plan on doing it again this year. I am also doing the Agatha Christie Challenge by reading 1/month in chronological order. I am also doing 2 other challenges. I was going to use separate books for all of them, but it was starting to stress me out. I decided to cross challenges, but not use the same book for multiple prompts within a challenge.
I love seeing how others work the challenge!


I like to be organized about my tasks so I have a Jotform list that has all the books I own and a separate sheet that has all the prompts and the book I plan to use. I will allow this to be flexible if needed. I have a column to check once the prompt has been completed.
As of now I am just picking and choosing the books I read in no particular order. That will probably adjust once I get further into the challenge.

I had thought about doing the prompts in order, but some of the books on my tbr would not sit by quietly waiting for me to get to them...
I don't plan to limit myself to one book a week, but I do plan to do all 52 + the mini-challenges.
It's not in my nature to limit myself to a specific author or genre. Generally, I'll read anything with words. But I've recently begun learning the graceful art of setting a book aside if it becomes...tedious or unreadable to me.
I don't really plan ahead with a book for each prompt, though I may think of titles to read for them... Sometimes that's part of the fun. I prefer to read what calls to me and figure out where to fit it later. On the other hand, some of the prompts are unique enough that when I read a book that definitely fits, I'll pencil it in. But I'm not opposed to moving it around later.
Other challenges? None of the formal ones. Wouldn't know which ones to choose, or where to find them. I have some personal goals: A Dewey challenge (one book from each of the broad dewey decimal categories), a specific list of genres and series, a decades challenge. And a percentage of the books read need to be books already in my possession at the New Year's bell. (This year, I'm trying for 50%.)

Right now I'm skipping around in the prompts and planning ahead about 5 books at a time in order to get some of the books on hold at the library. I also have a few books sitting around on my TBR shelves at home that I feel more encouraged (maybe even mild pressure) to read to fit the prompts.


My personal goals of reading in general for this year are to read a mix of nonfiction & fiction. Read 25% of my books this year from my actual shelf. I am more drawn to getting my books from the library as well as challenge myself with more lengthy books (400+ page books ). I also want to use books that have been on my TBR if at all possible.
I know from previous reading adventures I've tried that I can't plan everything out exactly and into the strict order or I start to hate the challenge and not enjoying the reading. So my approach this time is to have books that are on my TBR list and choose what I want to read at the time (mood, season, etc) and figure out what prompt that can check off. I'm hoping i don't move too many around, but I don't feel like I will be too strict. I have a running list of books and what prompts they meet in my Notes section on my phone. So I choose from that list and go from there. So far so good.
I may try some of the mini challenges, but Idk if I will really stress myself with them... probably depends on how the challenge is going.
I'm going to try to read all 52, but there are a couple that I may not be able to read just because of interest in the prompt.





My initial idea was to complete the challenge reading one book each week and each book in order, but I've already gone astray. The main goal is to complete the Challenge by reading all the 52 book that I've choose to fit the prompts.
This week I read Gone Girl (prompt 3: title starting with the letter G, ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️) and Bossypants (prompt 40: written by a commedian, ⭐️⭐️+1/2).
I am also doing the Agatha Christie Challenge!

I am doing the 52 books in 52 weeks, but as my overall reading goal for the year is 70 books, I am definitely reading other books in between what I have planned out. I have planned simply so I can try and use books I have already bought but have not yet read, or to make sure I am reading things in my "Want to Read" list. Even though I am reading books in between that may fit into certain prompts, I am purely seeing them as extra-credit reading!
As I love to read a bit of everything, I have a mixed bag of genres planned, and try to read from authors of different backgrounds where I can.
So far for the challenge I have read:
Prompt #1 - Taste: My Life through Food
Prompt #2 - Jane Eyre
Currently Reading Prompt #3 - Gallant

Kayla, just because you said you liked structure and it is your first time, be aware that there are mini challenges that come up, usually 5 to 6 a year. It is revealed at the beginning of the month and will have a theme and has 3 prompts. It totally threw me off last year. by the end of the year I was enjoying them, but the surprise of it at first was too much. They aren't mandatory, but I wanted to give you a heads up.

Thanks Anna! I did see that and tried to search what the mini challenges are - that's ok, if I can make the prompts work with the the other books I am reading in between then I will :)

I plan on tackling all 52 prompts. I tend to stick to my favourite genre, so this is a good way to go out of my comfort zone.
So far I've read 4 books, and I managed to find a prompt for each of them:
The Scum Villain's Self-Saving System: Ren Zha Fanpai Zijiu Xitong (Novel) Vol. 4 (35: Book you meant to read last year)
Days of Blood & Starlight (26: Has an epilogue)
The Book Thief (28: Includes a funeral)
The Bear and the Nightingale (34: Featuring mythology)

I'm a fairly slow reader, but am quite relaxed about that. Having read two longer books so far this year, I'm going for The Turn of the Screw by Henry James for the 200 pages or less prompt.

I don't complete the prompts in order but pre-planned out my books this year to make it easier to complete. I read books as they become available from the library or as I receive them (BOTM Club member). My goal is to complete all of them this year, and I've already swapped some in and out as I realized I didn't want to read a book a few chapters in.
Finally, I was able to cruise through four more promts:
- With Love from London by Sarah Jio (2: Featuring An Inheritance)
- Till We Have Faces by C.S. Lewis (34: Featuring Mythology)
- How to Do Nothing: Resisting the Attention Economy by Jenny Odell (51: Doesn’t Fit Any of The Other 51 Prompts)
- The House on Mango Street by Sandra Cisneros (6: Under 200 Pages)


I have a personal side challenge to read a book with the month in the title each month (example: January was The Ten Thousand Doors of January)
I'm also doing two other challenges (PopSugar and SFFBC) but they have a lot of overlap and I was able to do all three plus the summer genre challenge last year.

This year I am trying to follow the prompts in order. I have already had to rearrange and switch out titles because I get 100% of my books online through (now) Libby and have to time everything just right. I am having a blast doing this AND am creating a lovely TBR list just for books I still want to read but the timing isn't working. I plan to use those titles to fill in the prompts for the 2018 challenge. My goals are to 1) finish 2023 completely in order; 2) pause to do mini-challenges; if it doesn't make my "house of cards" collapse; 3) go back to 2018 and do those out of order, as the mood hits me, and only with books I truly WANT to read; 4) make a new goal, possibly completing all the mini-challenges from previous years or starting 2019; 5) post the title, author, and prompt with its number for every 4 books I complete as my contribution to those still looking for titles; and finally 6) not to read any book I despise - nothing under a 3-star-for-me book. As for the 2023 mini-challenges, I fully intend to extend myself as much grace as needed in terms of start/stop date due to when books are available. This means I might not finish a Feb challenge until March or whatever.
As for personal reading goals outside of these challenges, I try to always include a mix of fiction and nonfiction, "junk food" books and brainy books, classics and contemporary, international and U.S. authors, BIPOC and LGBTQA+ authors/characters, and deep dives into difficult and controversial subjects like immigration, healthcare, voting rights, etc. My LIFETIME goal is to use my love of reading to constantly grow my understanding, respect, and love for the other 7.888 billion people currently living on this itty bitty planet with me.





I'm not reading in any particular order. So far I have completed 6 books and am working on 2 more (I read a book and listen to a different book at the same time. The only prompt I'm not planning to do is 48 A Book by Octavia Butler. I started Wild Seed





Mini-challenges. It depends on which one. If I have to watch the film in the same quarter than I read the book for the book/film one, I might not do it--if I can read a book for something I've already seen, then I may. I don't usually watch film adaptations, although some are quite good. If it wasn't supposed to be a book under 200 pages, I'd have already one one where I did both this month!
By Jan 15 I'd finished my 5th book for this (it goes quickly at the beginning of the year when I can usually use things I'm already reading) which was The Lager Queen of Minnesota for a book featuring siblings, although it can work for more than one.



I do a mix of planning and reading what I find. I will use more library & Kindle Unlimited books than books I own, although I do buy some and reread favorites. I am working on my seventh prompt and eleventh book.

This year I have only finished 2 books. The Help #37 and A Game of Thrones #43 and I am almost done with One of Us Is Lying #28. I may change the prompt numbers depending on what is picked for me next month.


This is my 2nd year with this challenge and I'm very excited. My goal is to finish all 52 prompts and really pushing myself to also meet my GoodReads Reading Challenge of 70 books in 2023. So, with this I will also be working toward the Ultimate PopSugar Reading Challenge and two of the GoodReads Reading Challenges: A to Z: Locations and I-SPY Challenge. I came close last year to completing this challenge but fell short by a few prompts. This year I'm trying to read books that will work on the other challenges I'm working on. And, because I get most of my books from thrift stores (I have a problem...LOL) I do have most of the books I need for the year.
I wish you all luck with your personal goals!!
Happy Reading,
Lisa



I have seen the posts about mini challenges but am unsure what they are--i guess they are separate from the main challenge but themed? I would do one if it's a theme I like
Books mentioned in this topic
Haunted Greenwich Village: Bohemian Banshees, Spooky Sites, And Gonzo Ghost Walks (other topics)The Help (other topics)
A Game of Thrones (other topics)
One of Us Is Lying (other topics)
The Lager Queen of Minnesota (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Tom Ogden (other topics)Sarah Jio (other topics)
Sandra Cisneros (other topics)
C.S. Lewis (other topics)
Jenny Odell (other topics)
More...
January 15, 2023 -- Week 3
We're starting our third week of the 2023 challenge. Everyone tackles the challenge a little differently and we'd love to hear YOUR personal approach to this 52 Book Club challenge.
Some examples:
- Are you completing the challenge in order?
- Are you limiting yourself to one book a week?
- Is your goal to complete all 52 books? 26 books? All the mini-challenges too?
- Are you only reading [insert specific] authors or genres?
- Working through previous 52 Book Club challenges? Or other outside challenges?
- Planned it out exactly? Reading and filling in prompts as you go along?
- Only using books you already own?
- Are you letting yourself move books around throughout the year? Or once you match it to a prompt are you locking it in?
-Etc.
There are so many ways to mix this challenge up and make it your own. There are no wrong ways and we want to hear YOUR approach for this year!