2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #2 discussion

Avery goes to see Troy Hamilton and finds him brutally beaten to death. Josh was missing for a time and falls under suspicion. Did you ever consider that he could have done this? Why or why not?

I didn't think Josh killed his father, but I thought someone was setting him up for it. I didn't think that Josh would leave the safe house just to go home and kill Hamilton.

It seemed far fetched that Josh would have gone near Troy given his fear of him. Wasn’t sure he was being set up but I was convinced Josh’s fears were justified.

Josh wasn't the type. Run away - yes, Kill - no.

I didn't suspect Josh. He was too afraid of his father, and knew his father could take him down. I thought it was his mother who killed Troy initially.