♡ ya readers ౨ৎ ₊ ⊹ discussion

Once Upon a Broken Heart (Once Upon a Broken Heart, #1)
This topic is about Once Upon a Broken Heart
193 views
vi. ARCHIVE ♥ > ౨ৎ once upon a broken heart

Comments Showing 1-22 of 22 (22 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by bookworm ꣑ৎ‎ ˚. (more active), bookie ౨ৎ ₊ ⊹ (new) - rated it 4 stars

bookworm ꣑ৎ‎ ˚. (more active) | 3082 comments Mod
welcome to -ˏˋ꒰ouabh꒱ ´ˎ˗ discussion!!
✩‧₊˚ 100 points ੈ✩‧₊˚

˗ˏˋ♫ book playlist ♫ ´ˎ˗
https://open.spotify.com/playlist/4VY...

if u've already finished this book, please put spoiler warnings on ur messages bc others might not have read them yet!


message 2: by Johanna (new)

Johanna (5886046-johanna) | 19 comments I would love to read this but I have still the last two books unread in the original series 🙈


violet | 457 comments I have this as well 😭


Kai's Darling I've already read OUABH so, can I still log I'm the points in my house?


message 5: by bookworm ꣑ৎ‎ ˚. (more active), bookie ౨ৎ ₊ ⊹ (new) - rated it 4 stars

bookworm ꣑ৎ‎ ˚. (more active) | 3082 comments Mod
Hafsabookworm wrote: "I've already read OUABH so, can I still log I'm the points in my house?"

if u finished it in November, then yes — but if u haven’t then u can choose a special request to replace it (the SRB will count for 100 pts) 🎀🤍

see this link for the info: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...


Timeea (thebookfaereads) | 20 comments For those who already read it, opinions on the last book? I personally found it (kindda spoiler?) really disappointing compared to the first 2


message 7: by mariya (new)

mariya (mariya_aa) | 49 comments hii I was debating trying to read this, but I saw sm1 say to read caraval before it, do I rlly have to? No offence but I ain’t got all the times in the world to read the whole caraval series and then ouabh 😭🙏🏽 has any1 read it without reading caraval?


message 8: by bookworm ꣑ৎ‎ ˚. (more active), bookie ౨ৎ ₊ ⊹ (new) - rated it 4 stars

bookworm ꣑ৎ‎ ˚. (more active) | 3082 comments Mod
mariya wrote: "hii I was debating trying to read this, but I saw sm1 say to read caraval before it, do I rlly have to? No offence but I ain’t got all the times in the world to read the whole caraval series and th..."

u don’t have to read Caraval before it, but it helps give a BIT of context — if u don’t want to read Caraval before, maybe read ouabh and then Caraval?


message 9: by mariya (new)

mariya (mariya_aa) | 49 comments @bookworm ye I wanna read caraval eventually loll


Aves ౨ৎ (hi-its-aves) | 39 comments so I read this a while ago and i don't really want to read it again 'cause I didn't like the series so please ignore my rating. I updated my review recently but it does contain a lot of spoilers :)

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...


Bella The Bookworm (bellabuchanan) | 247 comments I love this book so much! I still have to read Caraval though, I asked for it for my birthday


《Dostoevsky's Sonya》 | 5 comments Timeea wrote: "For those who already read it, opinions on the last book? I personally found it (kindda spoiler?) really disappointing compared to the first 2"
Girl the third one was the one that rlly stood out to me


《Dostoevsky's Sonya》 | 5 comments So I have like a million questions for the last book. So it eneds with our two babies getting together, but is eva immortal now..? Bc shes gonna die eventually, or did jacks loose his immortality..? Like im so confused


littlefox (not as active) | 113 comments ♡Irene♡ wrote: "So I have like a million questions for the last book. So it eneds with our two babies getting together, but is eva immortal now..? Bc shes gonna die eventually, or did jacks loose his immortality....."

the curse was broken when evangeline kissed jacks because it was true love's kiss. his curse wasn't "any girl who kisses jacks dies" like we thought it was, it was actually "any girl who is attracted to jacks and kisses him dies, girls who don't care for him survive (which is why tella survived), but love breaks the curse"
basically, in true fairy tale fashion, true love broke the curse 🥹


message 15: by izzy of the hollow †, iz ౨ৎ ₊ ⊹ (last edited Nov 08, 2024 08:06AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

izzy of the hollow † (izzyofthehollow) | 1063 comments Mod
guys pls remember to put spoiler warnings on ur comments for other people who haven't read the book yet 😆💕💕


message 16: by Ivy (new)

Ivy Meshle | 215 comments Wait! When jacks kissed her? And what happened with girl's husband?


✮abby✮ | 20 comments i’m getting this from the library!


message 18: by Timeea (last edited Nov 16, 2024 09:52AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Timeea (thebookfaereads) | 20 comments ♡Irene♡ wrote: "So I have like a million questions for the last book. So it eneds with our two babies getting together, but is eva immortal now..? Bc shes gonna die eventually, or did jacks loose his immortality....."

HUGE SPOILERS!!
A lot of loose strings sadly. I think she isn't immortal, but he isn't a fate anymore as his curse has been lifted. The whole thing about fates is that they have a desire they long for and a goal they never get to reach, but he did (Lala explained it better), so that makes him free in a way. They're both mortals now imo.

My question is, will Lala forgive Castor and reciprocate the feelings or not??

And regarding Caraval, (spolier!) what happens after Tella literally sold her future daughter's soul. It's been 4 books since that happened and never mentioned again. I've been waiting for 3 years to get answers


message 19: by ari [semi ia], ari ౨ৎ ₊ ⊹ (new) - rated it 4 stars

ari [semi ia] | 2062 comments Mod
*sighs in just spoiled the whole series*

tbh i’m completely stupid and keep forgetting to log my books on this group 😅


Hannah | 19 comments I love Stephanie Garbers books so much and I love everything about them! I read OUABH before I read the Caraval series, and honestly it doesn’t matter which you read first but I’d recommend reading the Caraval series first before OUABH. I love Evangeline soooo much, and Jacks is just a chefs kiss character! I love the atmosphere of this book and I am practically in Stephanie’s world as I’m reading! I would definitely recommend reading this!!


message 21: by pip (new) - rated it 1 star

pip (pippiii) | 28 comments is it wrong i hated this book 😭


mimosa | 74 comments yes. okay, kidding, kidding! I'm curious: Why did you hate it, though?


back to top