⋆౨ৎ˚⟡˖ ࣪ reader & book girlies book club discussion

discuss our april botm, watch me, here!!

i read up to defy me i havent read the other books yet, should I? Everyone is so hyped about watch me and i feel left out i need to read themm

@Safiya yeah, i would read them! if you’re only reading the main books (without the novellas) then you only have one left after defy me.

tyy and i will probably read it after fearless (side note: the plot twist in fearless is CRAZYY)

IM SO EXCITED YALL IM PICKING IT UP FROM B&N TOMORROW

I THOUGHT IT CAME OUT TMRW AND THEN I SAW AN EDIT POSTED BY @erin AND I REMEMBERED YAY

MY COPY ARRIVES ON THURSDAY

Please tell me I'm not the only one who didn't like this at all...

The cover is soooo pretty

i’m eating this book up

@brianna fr especially james’s chapters i love him sm

the book is so pretty omg … i just started and im already eating it up

@K i understand why you wouldn’t like it, but i personally did. i gave it 3.75 stars, but that was mainly for james and the ogs. i didnt really like rosabelle

@erin agreed! I thought that it kind of felt like a long epilogue to the original series instead of the first book in a spin-off series if that makes sense? Like Tahereh Mafi did a great job of furthering the original plots/characters but not such a good job with new characters and plotlines. I still gave it 4.5 stars but now I’m wondering if that was just because of Warner😭

@mia fr. like, i don’t think i would’ve liked this book AT ALL if it weren’t for the ogs. james could’ve saved it slightly, but other than that i doubt i would’ve liked it.