Harry Potter vs Twilight discussion
Twilight vs Harry Potter
>
Severus Snape vs Carlisle Cullen
message 1:
by
Andy
(new)
May 20, 2010 08:25AM
[image error]
reply
|
flag
I don't know what to say to this one...I'd like to say Carlisle, but he's like a passifist or something, so Snape would be the only one fighting...
But if Carlisle was in trouble he'd fight, and win.
*** SPOILER FROM DEATHLY HALLOWS ***Ya, if a snake bite can kill snape, imagine what a vampire bite can do!
KILL youuuu and anyone else that sucks :P
ya if they suck all your blood your effed
Yes they do Im a vampire...in my dreams
yup and you can e with...............Leah
Andy wrote: "no but vampires dont exist"Neither to witches or wizards andy.
Again it would be a very cool fight to watch, but Carlise wouldn't fight unless he really needed to.
(that was weird the internet was messed up, was it for you too Becca? or Andy if your on here?)
BECCA! STOP SAYING THAT! THE POINT OF THE DISCUSSION IS THE FACT THAT THEY DOOOOO FIGHT!
Haha CARLISLE!! (did your internet mess up Andy?)
(well everyone in my classes did for like 5 minutes)
well mine did!! CARLISLE kicks butt!
Mine didn't either. Sorry Andy. I'm just thinking of what the characters would actually do!!
Snape. there is no question, he is the inventor of several spells and potions that could kill Carlisle.
i think Snape would have a huge advantage, yes.
Yeah. His main advantage being that he is willing to fight.
why is everyone from twilight a prat to you?
Yeah! Carlisle isn't a prat either. He is amazing, and I totally share his point of view.
Because they are. Twilight it's self is just a big prat. and i mean that in the nicest way possible.
i don't really have a definition for it, i just use it to describe people who annoy me greatly.
why do they annoy you? because they aren't in harry potter? If alice was in harry potter you would say "She's so deep, i love her background, and the fact that she doesn't know it, and i love her appearance and her power, and her personality, and her awesomeness, and she's nothing like someone from twilight, the prats." so just seriously...
ummm, no i don't like Alice because she is much to bubbly and her character was never greatly explored. I have reasons for not liking characters, not just because they are not in Harry Potter.
Her character was greatly explored througout the storym and even better, it wasn't just thrown in using the smart character, Meyer found a way to put it in without using Hermione, so.... ya.
*story...what? that part about smart characters and Hermione made no sense...
yes it did, everytime Rowling needed to put something in she just used Hermione. When Meyer had creative ways to do it.
Yeah. Alice is so deep and amazing and has a totally cool back story. Actually all of them have pretty cool backstories. I love that about Twilight.
i didn't get anything get any of that. sadly, Hermione is not just the informational one and i thought the stories were a bit boring.
