ROBUST discussion

Posted a review of Treespeakerhere and on Amazon.
4 stars to a great book!

Treespeaker just got another 4 star review from Tahlia Newland -

http://www.amazon.com/Treespeaker-ebo...

Now it's beginning to look like a real book! :)

Yes, Katie!!

Hurray, Katie!

Congrats.

Well done!

An interesting "tentative review" of Treespeaker from 'Mean Jane'! I've never had one of those before...

http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...

I have to admit, I do like the 'stunning cover' bit!

That is an odd review made by someone who hasn't read the book, just the sample. So are the stars for the cover? Or are the stars for the sample?

Interesting approach. Looks as if she is just getting her feet wet with reviewing.

I'm sure she will like the book as much as I did...

I've been waiting nervously for this review all year as I knew the reader had added Treespeaker to her list for the year, but she kept saying 'I don't like fantasy' (but I was in the Aussie group, so she added me anyway). I needn't have worried.

http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...

Very good!

Lovely!

{{ clap clap }}

And Katie goes marching on...

And I saw someone else picked it up based on that review. :-)

Dave wrote: "And I saw someone else picked it up based on that review. :-)"

Yes, added bonus!

(Nice to see you back, Dave!)

That one sale brought me another review. That's how it works, Messrs Ellory & Locke!

http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...

Drum roll please...

That is indeed how it works, Katie. And keeps working, because there is nothing to expose, and thus nobody to expose you.

I just received another wonderful five star review from someone on Kindle Users Forum. She really 'got' it!

http://www.amazon.co.uk/review/R167E2...

Nice.

Superb.

She sure did get it, Katie. That was wonderful!!

While I was looking at it, I thought I would have another look at my review. I was surprised to see it was not there. Then I remembered that in the past, reviews did not necessarily transfer over to other 'Zon sites. I was able to repost from .com to .co.uk, for what it is worth. It never occurred to me to check if my reviews had been replicated to other sites.

If this is the case with anyone else for whom I have written a review, please let me know and I will rectify...

That's a kind offer, Sharon.

Your review here:
http://www.amazon.com/MANS-novel-RUTH...
isn't here:
http://www.amazon.co.uk/product-revie...

It would be great if you could copy it over.

Thanks, Sharon! That was kind of you! :)

Done, Andre. Thanks for making it easy and providing both links. I checked on Iditarod and see that my review did get automatically posted on UK. When did Zon stop doing that? And why would they? Grrr...

My pleasure, Katie. I was surprised to see it hadn't replicated there. Really, Amazon knows very well how to automate something like that, and it should be a no-brainer that they would. It's not that I wrote the review(s) years ago before the UK site was established.

Off to send a note to customer service...

Some reviews do, some don't. I'm not sure what the difference is.

I did contact customer service, got a reply saying they were still beta-testing transfer. What's to test?