30 things to tell a book snob

People should read books. Books are good.

But many are intimidated. One of the reasons people are put off reading is snobbery. You know, the snobbery that says opera and lacrosse and Pinot Noir and jazz fusion and quails' eggs and literary fiction are for certain types of people and them alone?

There is something innately snobby about the world of books. There is the snobbery of literary over genre, of adult books over children's, of seriousness over comedy, of reality over fantasy, of Martin Amis over Stephen King. And it is unhealthy. If books ever die, snobbery would be standing over the corpse.

So here is my message to book snobs:

1. People should never be made to feel bad about what they are reading. People who feel bad about reading will stop reading.

2. Snobbery leads to worse books. Pretentious writing and pretentious reading. Books as exclusive members clubs. Narrow genres. No inter-breeding. All that fascist nonsense that leads commercial writers to think it is okay to be lazy with words and for literary writers to think it is okay to be lazy with story.

3. If something is popular it can still be good. Just ask Shakespeare. Or the Beatles. Or peanut butter.

4. Get over the genre thing. The art world accepted that an artist could take from anywhere he or she wanted a long time ago. Roy Lichtenstein could turn comic strips into masterpieces back in 1961. Intelligence is not a question of subject but approach.

5. It is harder to be funny than to be serious. For instance, this is a serious sentence: 'After dinner, Alistair roamed the formal garden behind this unfamiliar house, wishing he had never betrayed Lorelei's trust.' That took me eight seconds to write. And yet I've been trying to write a funny sentence for three hours now, and I'm getting hungry.

6. Many of the greatest writers have been children's writers.

7. It is easy to say something to people who are exactly like you. A bigger challenge lies in locating that universal piece of all of us that wants to be wowed, and brought together by a great story. There isn't a human in the world who wouldn't enter the Sistine Chapel and not want to look up. Does that make Michelangelo a low-brow populist?

8. It does not matter about who the author is. The only thing a book should be judged on is the words inside.

9. Martin Amis once moaned on the radio that there were too many writers talking across the table to their readers rather than down to them. This was the point I went off Martin Amis.

10. You don't have to be serious about something to be serious about something.

11. You don't have to be realistic to be true.

12. You are one of 7,000,000,000 people in the world. You can never be above all of them. But you can be happy to belong.

13. The only people who fear people understanding what they are saying are people who have nothing really to say.

14. Books are not better for being misunderstood, any more than a building is better for having no door.

15. Shakespeare didn't go to university, and spelt his name six different ways. He also told jokes. (Bad ones, true, but you can't knock him for trying.)

16. Avoiding plot doesn't automatically make you clever. (See: Greene, Tolstoy, Shakespeare.)

17. Freedom is a process of knocking down walls. Tyranny is a process of building them.

18. There can be as much beauty in short (words, sentences, paragraphs, chapters) as long. Sparrows fly higher than peacocks.

19. Snobs are suckers, because they have superficial prejudices.

20. The book I am least proud of, that I didn't work hard enough on, was my most ostentatiously highbrow one.

21. Reading a certain book doesn't make you more intelligent any more than drinking absinthe makes you Van Gogh. It's how you read, as much as what you read.

22. Never make someone feel bad for not having read or not read something. Books are there to heal, not hurt.

23. Imagination is play. Snobbery is the opposite of play.

24. I used to be a snob. It made me unhappy.

25. Simple isn't always stupid. When I write a first draft it is complicated. There is mess. The second and third and fifteenth drafts try and get it to make sense, to trim away the frayed edges.

26. Stephen King was right. Books are 'portable magic'. And everyone loves magic.

27. Inclusion is harder than exclusion. Just ask a politician.

28. The brain can absorb many things. So can a novel.

29. For me, personally, the point of writing is to connect me to this world, to my fellow humans. We are all miles apart. We have no real means of connecting except via language. And the deepest form of language is storytelling.

30. The greatest stories appeal to our deepest selves, the parts of us snobbery can't reach, the parts that connect the child to the adult and the brain to the heart and reality to dreams. Stories, at their essence, are enemies of snobbery. And a book snob is the enemy of the book.
700 likes ·   •  37 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on November 06, 2013 07:29 Tags: book-snobs, books, reading, snobbery, snobs
Comments Showing 1-37 of 37 (37 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by ML (new)

ML you might as well blog for people for people who enjoy reading!


message 2: by Maggie (new)

Maggie I think I needed to read this. I have given a couple friends hell for reading the Twilight books simply because of the lack of good literature involved and following a trend. Same thing with 50 shades. At least they're reading! Thank you.


message 3: by ColumbusReads (new)

ColumbusReads I'd like to take #27, especially, and claim it as my own. Thanks for this and I'll share it with friends. Oh, and give you all the credit!


message 4: by Gerhard (new)

Gerhard Aren't we all book snobs in one way or another? I think the key is to tolerate our mutual snobbery.


message 5: by Joanne (new)

Joanne Harris Matt. I think I love you.


message 6: by Samuel (new)

Samuel Allister That...or everyone acts like a snob and we raise real snobs standards


message 7: by Joanne (new)

Joanne Harris Seconded, thirded and taken home to meet the cat.


message 8: by Gerhard (new)

Gerhard Samuel wrote: "That...or everyone acts like a snob and we raise real snobs standards"

Snobs don't have standards; they have expectations. ;)


message 9: by Hannah (new)

Hannah My favourite thing about book snobs is that they look down on "mainstream" fiction (some of them even call it "trashy" - rude) but a lot of classics were the popular books/plays/poems of their day. Doesn't that make them "mainstream" too?


message 10: by Olga (new)

Olga Reading is pleasure and so much joy, you live in the story in other people's heads, it is miraculous, educational, healing, though-provoking, everything and anything and no way it is snobbish. To me reading is mostly Pleasure and Enjoyment no matter how sad the topic might be.


message 11: by Kerin (new)

Kerin Dear Mr Haig,
I am a self proclaimed book snob. I dislike most of the popular books (Girl on the Train, Gone Girl-you get the idea). I would never ever think of discouraging anyone from reading. However if I ask you what type of book you like to read and the response is "murder mysteries", or Nicholas Sparks, I will tactfully change the subject. I loved every word, every sentence, and every character in your book The Humans....
Don't judge.


message 12: by Carla (new)

Carla Profound.


message 13: by Beth (new)

Beth Lawson Matt: Such a breath of fresh air, your blog post is! I grew up surrounded by book snobs, which turned me right off reading - and as a child I was an advanced reader. At parent's night, my teachers would beg my folks to provide reading material for me to use in my free time, but they would agonise over what was appropriate, what was not, and would they be judged for what they gave me...? Horrors! Instead, I had nothing at all. I was even discouraged from checking out books from the library, in case I picked up something "silly". (People, don't do this to your kids!) This constant, snobby judgement discouraged me from reading well into adulthood. I've only recently said "f**k it" and I read what I want. Everyone should.

Some of the comments here seem to have missed your point, which is to read what you like. We don't have to read every piece of careless rubbish out there in order to avoid being book snobs. We can still have our personal standards. OUR standards, not someone else's.

And thank you for your wonderfully honest interview with Bryony Gordon on her podcast. I will now pick up your books, because they will be enjoyed.


message 14: by Mir (new)

Mir 5. It is harder to be funny than to be serious. For instance, this is a serious sentence: 'After dinner, Alistair roamed the formal garden behind this unfamiliar house, wishing he had never betrayed Lorelei's trust.' That took me eight seconds to write. And yet I've been trying to write a funny sentence for three hours now, and I'm getting hungry.

But then you succeeded in writing a funny sentence, so treat yourself to a peanut butter sandwich and a glass of white wine.

24. I used to be a snob. It made me unhappy.

I suspect many people become snobs because they're already unhappy.


message 15: by Gab (new)

Gab This is such a great post! Thanks! Also, I've just finished reading "Reasons to Stay Alive" and I wanted to tell you how much I loved it!! I have depression and when I started reading your book I was not in a good place. I'm a little better now, but a LOT better for having read your brilliant book. Thank you so much for writing it.


kittykat AKA Ms. Tortitude Hannah (Ivyclad Ideas) wrote: "My favourite thing about book snobs is that they look down on "mainstream" fiction (some of them even call it "trashy" - rude) but a lot of classics were the popular books/plays/poems of their day...."

3 years later I'm discovering this thread... and I can't agree enough about that word trashy being used to describe lots of mainstream fiction, especially areas that are primarily both written and consumed by women. To say that I hate the term is putting it mildly.

I have to say that I agree with virtually everything that Matt Haig has said in this blog post, and in particular
3. If something is popular it can still be good. Just ask Shakespeare. Or the Beatles. Or peanut butter.

14. Books are not better for being misunderstood, any more than a building is better for having no door.

17. Freedom is a process of knocking down walls. Tyranny is a process of building them.
but do take exception to
8. It does not matter about who the author is. The only thing a book should be judged on is the words inside.


There are some of us that are unable or more to the point unwilling to separate the art from its creator for reasons such as virulent hate towards various groups of people that are different to themselves, or whom they "disagree" with such as females, queers and POC's amongst others. Or those that partake in various heinous crimes against other humans which has sometimes included their own children. There are even some 'artists' who try to copyright common words used in certain genres and then try to sue their peers for using the same word in their own novels prior to the copyright claim.

Whether the artist is still alive or now dead, some of us retain the right to choose not to support the work that was created at the same time as perpetuating various levels of hatred, crime or even just bad behavior against others.

I do believe that one of Mr Haig's rules should be to not judge others on their reasons for choosing or not choosing to consume to works of certain artists, even if it is nothing to do with the work itself. Afterall, there are plenty of other readers out there who will just ignore those issues and pay for and consume the works, and that is their right too.


message 17: by Cheryl (new)

Cheryl Matt, I'm so grateful to you for this post, and for Reasons to Stay Alive. I look forward to reading your novels.


message 18: by Alice (last edited Sep 13, 2020 03:30PM) (new)

Alice Dear Matt,
I am a librarian. I buy books for my library district in Colorado. Your points about not being a book snob are wonderful.

I am one of the few librarians I know who admits she loves romances. One time a patron came to my desk and asked me to help her find some romances. She was told that I liked them--by a condescending book snob. I found some of my favorites for her. The woman told me that her seven-year old son had died the week before, and she needed something to give her a little bit of happiness. That is a true story. It's why when I buy books, I always try to envision the people who will love reading them.

I just finished The Midnight Library. I have been so depressed during COVID. Your book made a huge difference to me. I wrote down the line "Librarians are like soul-enhanced search engines." I changed careers twenty years ago. It felt like becoming a librarian was what I was always meant to do, but that I needed to do other things first to find the best job, one with a great purpose. Thank you so much.
Alice


message 19: by Cybercrone (new)

Cybercrone Gab wrote: "This is such a great post! Thanks! Also, I've just finished reading "Reasons to Stay Alive" and I wanted to tell you how much I loved it!! I have depression and when I started reading your book I w..."
READ MIDNIGHT LIBRARY!! I have been in an increasingly dark place for several months.
I think Todd Haig saved my life today.


message 20: by Suzanne (last edited Dec 28, 2020 09:53AM) (new)

Suzanne LaPierre It's funny that I read this blog post right after posting a review of The Midnight Library in which I started by admitting that I can be a prose snob but I loved the book (which I gave five stars). As a librarian, I try to read all kinds of books so that I can make recommendations to people who ask based on what kinds of books they love to read.

People read for different reasons: some to be inspired, educated, or entertained, some to relax or escape. So- definitely no judgement. People should read what they love but maybe try to stretch a little sometimes too.

Graphic novels are probably the books I hear most often abused by people who come into the library, as in "I want books for my kid to read- s/he likes those comic books, but I want him/her to read REAL books." This makes me especially sad because: (1) Kids who like graphic novels are often at that fragile age where they may turn off books altogether if not allowed to pursue their own interests. Studies show kids are more likely to pursue reading when they get to choose their own material. And (2) there are some beautifully conceived and realized graphic novels wherein the visuals complement the text to a magical extent- these are so deserving of attention, not dismissal. (And some are just laugh-out-loud funny, and who doesn't need a laugh?)

But I digress- in short, "no" to book snobbery- but also please don't refer to people who genuinely prefer literary fiction or classics as snobs because they also have a right to find joy in their tomes of choice without shame. Personally, I tend to gravitate towards literary fiction or nonfiction most often, but have found great reading pleasure in everything from scifi to picture books. Quality isn't limited to any one genre- know what you like, but also explore a little!


message 21: by Elaine (new)

Elaine Fultz, Teacher Librarian, MLS Thanks so much for this! I will share with my students highlighting #6.


message 22: by Robert (last edited Jan 09, 2021 03:00PM) (new)

Robert I think you could have made one point that would have saved you putting this entire list together- get rid of the Booker prize. I rest my case.


message 23: by Marla (new)

Marla This list and the list in The Humans --- you write these lists because it would take too long to write a novel for each brilliant observation? Yes? No?


message 24: by Manuel (new)

Manuel I started to reading seriously a couple months ago and I'm loving it. I truly don't wanna lose this enthusiasm. And the things Haig have said are some of the reasons I Won't. Thank you, Sir.


message 25: by Flor (last edited Mar 28, 2021 06:12PM) (new)

Flor Ross El esnobismo me ha llevado a dejar de leer, hasta que un día me animé a leer lo que deseaba en ese momento sin pensar. Leer solo por el deseo de meterme en un mundo.
Leo lo que quiero, lo que deseo y no prejuzgo. Y dejo los libros con los que me aburro.
Cada uno lee lo que quiere.
Me gusta mucho esta lista y me la guardé.


message 26: by Patricia (new)

Patricia I enjoyed reading the list, but I don't agree with the premise.

I love books. They are everywhere in my home. I haven't read all the books that I own; I don't think I ever will. But, it's a comfort just to have them.

I don't see book snobbery. The author doesn't know who will read her creation or what the reader will take away from the book. Whether its being read by members of a book club, or by someone who picked up the paperback for 25 cents at a yard sale.

In fact, I see reading as the great equalizer. A high school dropout can connect with Shakespeare, or Harper Lee, or Dan Brown... maybe all three.

As we grow and change we read the same material differently. I love To Kill a Mockingbird. I first read it in high school; I've seen the movie version several times; I reread To Kill a Mockingbird 30 years later; I saw Aaron Sorkin's version on Broadway. It's the same story, but its different each time I connect with it.

Instead of using To Kill a Mockingbird to make that point, I could have said something about War and Peace, or Pride and Prejudice, or The Red and the Black. Would one of these have made me a snob? Well, maybe the Red and the Black.

Reading is generally a solitary activity. No one has to know what you are reading unless you share the information.

Snobbery isn't about books, its about the snob. What do I wear, or drive? Where do I live? Where do I vacation? What wine do I drink? Snobbery is about insecurity, and lack of self confidence. It is form over substance. Reading is the opposite, it is substance over form.

These are just some thoughts of a lifetime reader.


message 27: by Liza (new)

Liza Martini You had me at number two: "All that fascist nonsense that leads commercial writers to think it is okay to be lazy with words and for literary writers to think it is okay to be lazy with story."


message 28: by Kimberly R (new)

Kimberly R This. Is. AWESOME!!!!


message 29: by Nate (new)

Nate This was quite possibly the most redeeming piece I've read not only with regard to snobby readers but to snobby writers. As a writer of "fun" books, I desperately needed this.

I just started reading The Midnight Library, and I'm loving it. Thank you, Matt Haig---I'm glad you are now on my radar.


message 30: by Susan's Reviews (last edited Dec 22, 2021 10:21AM) (new)

Susan's Reviews kittykat AKA Jo Tortitude wrote: "Hannah (Ivyclad Ideas) wrote: "My favourite thing about book snobs is that they look down on "mainstream" fiction (some of them even call it "trashy" - rude) but a lot of classics were the popular ..."
Hmmm, I hear you, and I've ripped a few such authors apart in my reviews, but freedom of speech is a right that I hold very sacred and it upsets me when I read about schools banning books etc.
Make your voice heard in opposition, by all means. We can be such Stupid Humans, but sometimes we learn from our mistakes. Tolerance can't be doled out in half measures, but I do understand your anger and unhappiness. Change is slow to come - we can't erase their hateful thinking and force them to be more tolerant, alas.


message 31: by Susan's Reviews (new)

Susan's Reviews I love the way Matt Haig things! What he must have suffered, though, to get to this deep understanding of what we need to do to get by in this media-dominated, flashy world. For so many of us, being truly, sincerely and unashamedly yourself is almost impossible these days, what with all the social/media feeds that glamorize a sandwich or fruit plate at a restaurant (or a flashy car/glamorous outfit/billion dollar wedding celebration) at any given moment. Many are focusing on the wrong THINGS once again in their media posts... Gotta love Matt Haig! As my niece would say: you are The Man!


message 32: by Luci (new)

Luci Huzzah! Too damn many people don't read at all. Better they read for entertainment than not. Because reading is a weapon against stupidity. Oops.. bit of snobbery slipped in there.


message 33: by Charlie (new)

Charlie Thanks Matt Haig =)
Thus was really uplifting, especially after having to listen to some real-life booksnobs earlier.
Your books helped me through.
Thansfor doing what you do.


message 34: by Diane (new)

Diane I was just talking to a friend about your books, and I thought I'd drop by and give you a hearty THANK YOU! You make the world a bit better! - Diane


message 35: by Diane (last edited Jun 19, 2023 03:52PM) (new)

Diane Shearn The long somewhat academic list really counters the point you are trying to make, I feel.

N.B. A book can be good, but it doesn’t mean it’s literature.
Discuss.

☺️


message 36: by Cheetahtrout (new)

Cheetahtrout Thank you. I really needed to read this, since for far too long I read books deemed "fitting my age" and often feel (unnessecarily) ashamed when picking up a "kids book".

I think the whole snobism in books thing is very old. The first printed books where only something rich people could buy ( often they couldnt even read the books they owned ). Later, in Victorian times Bibliomania broke out anew. Suddenly people profiled and measured their wealth and worth in rare books to brag about at the clubs, even if they never read them!
Nowadays many young readers get repelled by schools forceing them to read books they dont want to, wich only makes matters worse.

Thank you again! I have some friends who really need to hear this too.


message 37: by Murat (last edited Apr 26, 2024 04:35AM) (new)

Murat AYDIN If I understand correctly, the term "snobbery of literary" refers to critics (reader or professional critics) who want to sound marginal, giving the image of being either unconventional or intellectual. In general, I am also against such individuals, but here is another fact: Life is not long enough to read all the books. Therefore, it matters what we expect from a book and what impression we get from it. Ultimately, making a conscious and qualified selection for reading is the culture every reader should get. Within this context, I may tolerate criticisms of a book (same for any product, movie, etc.) which will provide me with rational guidance to spend my resources on time, money, and effort, unless these criticisms are rude, arrogant, and destructive.


back to top