Play Book Tag discussion

Autumn (Seasonal Quartet, #1)
This topic is about Autumn
16 views
Footnotes > Buddy read for Autumn by Ali Smith

Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Booknblues | 12060 comments Some of us were doing a buddy read of Autumn this month for Trim the TBR. Anyone wishing to join in is welcome to do so.


Jgrace | 3937 comments I read it, but it's been a while. I'll be interested to hear what others think of it. (This might inspire a reread)


Booknblues | 12060 comments So, I've finished it but hope my buddies for this read will come on board for a discussion.

Just a few thoughts and questions:

What do you think of how it starts and the book references in it?
It was the worst of times, it was the worst of times. Again. That’s the thing about things. They fall apart, always have, always will, it’s in their nature.

Do you like the shifting narratives in this book?

Are you connecting to the characters in Autumn?

Thoughts on the writing style?


message 4: by Diana (last edited Mar 10, 2022 11:07AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Diana Hryniuk | 837 comments Booknblues wrote: "So, I've finished it but hope my buddies for this read will come on board for a discussion.

Just a few thoughts and questions:

What do you think of how it starts and the book references in it?
I..."


Really interesting questions, Booknblues! I hope I'll be able to start reading the book in a few days. And I'll surely share my thoughts on it:)


Booknblues | 12060 comments Diana H. wrote: "Really interesting questions, Booknblues! I hope I'll be able to start reading the book in a few days. And I'll surely share my thoughts on it:) ..."

Get to it when you can. I know that you have other things on your mind, so I thought I would leave so questions here for when you can read it.


Diana Hryniuk | 837 comments Booknblues wrote: "So, I've finished it but hope my buddies for this read will come on board for a discussion.

Just a few thoughts and questions:

What do you think of how it starts and the book references in it?
I..."


I thought that this beginning was some kind of allusion to Autumn - how everything "falls apart" in autumn.

The shifting narratives were very confusing for me. Sometimes I even forgot who I'm reading about.

And I didn't connect to the characters of the novel. We don't know much about them, so they didn't seem very real to me or close.

I can't say the writing style is bad. Sometimes it's really poetic. But for me, it wasn't always easy to comprehend.


Booknblues | 12060 comments Diana H. wrote: "Booknblues wrote: "So, I've finished it but hope my buddies for this read will come on board for a discussion.

Just a few thoughts and questions:

What do you think of how it starts and the book ..."


I'm so glad you were able to finish.
I didn't love her style, either.

What brought it forward for me were thoughts about family and what makes a family. The book I read after this one had an older man and an adolescent woman in which he acted as her father. Reading two such books made me look back on Autumn a little more fondly.


back to top